Fishing Report,    fly fishing the upper sac,    upper sac,    Upper Sacramento,    upper sacramento river

Holy Crap, That's Some Cold Shit (or, Fly Fishing The Upper Sac In Winter)

By Tom Chandler 11/20/2011

Things got sticky after the #22 Quigley Cripple disappeared in a swirl and I lifted the fly rod.

I got a pair of those ponderous head shakes that tell you the fish is big (or he's foul hooked), and then the reel went from zero to ohmigod speeds in a fraction of a second.

That's thrilling stuff, but hardly Jack London-esque -- unless the fast-moving trout decides to run under the only laydown on the whole run.

Well played, Mr. Trout.

Upper Sac Rainbow trout (winter caught)

I waded over and sized up the situation. The trout was still on, apparently hanging around just downstream trying to figure out what was going on.

The fly line dove under the tree and made a right-angle exit downriver.

I remember thinking "I can fix this. This won't be too bad at all."

Which is when things started to go sideways.

Hey, This Clear Liquid Is Cold

Sometimes -- for brief moments -- I fancy myself a Man of Action, though at my age, you'd think I'd connect those moments with what inevitably follows.

Which is generally humiliation.

I waded up to the downed tree, put the rod in my left hand, reached down into the water with my right (a lot farther down than I originally thought, which should have been a clue), and lifted the tree.

So far, so good.

But sliding the rod under the tree took me a little deeper than I anticipated, and that extra couple inches meant the top of my waders (and the side of my head, and the neck opening of my jacket) got... submerged.

At the time it happened I realized it was trouble, but I'd started and you know how it is -- you're already there so you decide to brazen it out.

I distinctly remember straightening up -- a huge wad of wet, decomposing leaves clutched in my hand along with my still-attached-to-the-trout fly rod -- thinking I had the fish and I was still dry.

Which is when the 39 degree water hit my skin.

It kinda takes your breath away.

Shrinkage was body-wide and immediate.

I managed to land that trout -- the second of the day. It went between 18 and 19 inches (Raine put measuring wraps on my rod at 16" and 18", suggesting a distinct lack of faith in my ability to catch 20" trout).

The other trout fell just short of the 18" mark.

I was wet enough that I squished when I walked, though -- thank god for the Nano Puff jacket -- I warmed up a bit after I got past the shock, though my feet never really enjoyed the trip.

Taken as a whole, that's still not a bad day.

The Nitty Gritty Details

The air was around 40 degrees, the BWO hatch was light and only lasted an hour, but I still managed to get seven rising fish to eat the bug.

At just under one grab every eight minutes, that's Happy Hour as far as I'm concerned.

The hook popped out of three with only slight resistance (it's a #22 cripple after all), and I landed two of the four I hooked.

That's not a stirring percentage -- and I sometimes catch myself wondering WWGD (What Would Gierach Do) -- but the fish are big and the hook gape is probably best measured with an electron microscope, so I've largely done away with fly fisherman's remorse.

The 8'3" 5wt Raine hollowbuilt has confirmed its status as a killer BWO rod -- you need to make longer casts than you think on this stretch because wading any closer means the trout simply stop rising.

Thirty feet is a gift. Forty is common, and casting at an upstream or downstream angle can leave you with surprisingly little fly line on your reel.

It's cold up here (we've got two inches of snow on the ground as I write this), but we've reached the Bonus Portion of the year; the "real" Upper Sac winter when the little fish go into hiding and the big fish start eating BWOs -- provided the hatches come, the sun stays behind a cloud, you're on the right piece of river, and the fly fishermen don't wade too close.

See you on the river (literally), Tom Chandler

AuthorPicture

Tom Chandler

As the author of the decade leading fly fishing blog Trout Underground, Tom believes that fishing is not about measuring the experience but instead of about having fun. As a staunch environmentalist, he brings to the Yobi Community thought leadership on environmental and access issues facing us today.

19 comments
I bought a Nano and pull it on during backcountry skiing breaks. Admittedly the temperatures in California mountains hover around a "warm" 32 degrees, but you feel the Nano spread this glow of warmth around you. It's also become my summer backpacking insulation of choice because it's warm, weighs only 9 ounces and it stuffs easily into spare crannies in my backpack. When you wake up and it's still ... more just below freezing, it has kept me warm like no other piece I've own. At least until I get that first cup of hot coffee in me and start to sweat a little.
0
0
Gregg; Good question. Maybe I should just write a post about how I survive winter and invite everyone else to pile on with their tips.
0
0
Gregg: Tom, I'm curious about your layering to keep warm in those air temperatures. I've been salivating over a Nano, but having a hard time understanding just how warm they are. Can you compare it to another type of jacket? What did the Nano replace? What do you wear under the Nano to keep warm at those temperatures?Thanks,Gregg G.-Check out the Nano Puff pullovers on Ebay for just under a benjamin ... more plus shipping. I like Patagonia's philosophy of using recycled polyester for their top layer . tw
0
0
Tom, I'm curious about your layering to keep warm in those air temperatures. I've been salivating over a Nano, but having a hard time understanding just how warm they are. Can you compare it to another type of jacket? What did the Nano replace? What do you wear under the Nano to keep warm at those temperatures? Thanks, Gregg
0
0
I once had to move a log for the very same reason. Fortunately, the log I moved was only in knee deep water so all I had to suffer was a very wet arm for the remainder of the day. I hope you've unshrunk.
0
0
Curious, I am jealous, humored and thinking "crazy basterd" all at the same time!
0
0
A dunkin' to be proud of, Tom. I be grinning ear-to-ear just reading about it.
0
0
I think 16" trout are considered steelhead in California too -- at least on rivers reaching the ocean. On the Lower Sac, my fish would have been considered steelhead (at least I *think* that's the case). On the Upper Sac, they're not little steelhead, they're big trout, and I think I prefer it that way.
0
0
Tom Chandler: I found myself doing the same when fishing in Idaho during the winter, and it worked — right up until I hooked a trout big enough to take a little line… Your comment just triggered a knee jerk response, ODWF uses phony counting tools in order to deflect attention from their their poor management job. Trout on the Rogue River over 16" are now considered an adult Steelhead! You ... more just caught 2 (Rogue count) steelhead... congats! tw
0
0
Nice read. This is first year in a long time I didn't get up to the Upper Sac. Sounds like a great day! There is just something extra special about winter fishing.
0
0
"Shrinkage was body-wide and immediate." Great post! Nice fish! Glad you didn't freeze.
0
0
well done ol' man. :)
0
0
I found myself doing the same when fishing in Idaho during the winter, and it worked -- right up until I hooked a trout big enough to take a little line...
0
0
Jim Yaussy Albright: WWGD? He'd feel damned proud of the whole trip. Good one. Actually, I was thinking about the low hooking percentage stuff, but figure the whole "keep tightening until the rod is really *bent* method is still the best for tiny hooks.
0
0
Fishing is a summer sport for the same reason brown liquor is a winter drink: thermodynamics.
0
0
This reminds me of fishing the Upper Rogue in Dec. In order to cast, I sometimes have to dip my rod in the water in order to un-freeze the line in my guides. Nano, or no Nano.. you just can't get warm. tw
0
0
Wow, with a shrinkage factor of 11 like that I think maybe you start referring to the Upper Sac as the Little Sack. WWGD, thats a good one.
0
0
WWGD? He'd feel damned proud of the whole trip. Good one.
0
0
Gives me the chills just thinking about it. And I really do need to check into that Nano Puff.
0
0

Discover Your Own Fishing and Hunting Adventures

With top destinations, guided trips, outfitters and guides, and river reports, you have everything you need.