The Trout Underground Fly Fishing Blog

  • Home
  • Why?
  • Colophon
  • Links
  • Contact

Underground’s Best

The Underground’s 2009 Year in Review (in Words & Pictures)

December 31, 2009, by Tom Chandler 12 comments

With only a few hours left in 2009, it’s probably time I actually started writing my “The Underground Looks Back at 2009: The Year in Mirth & Pictures” post.

And while the Underground’s fly fishing-related theme for 2009 has to be that smaller is better (I was on an extended small stream jag most of 2009), not everything that found its way to the Underground was about the little stuff.

Fly fishing a small stream was the Underground's theme in 2009

A recurring theme in 2009 was our obsession with small streams...

First, the Underground threw a brick through his own plate glass window and became a father.

That’s the kind of statement that requires a little pause, and maybe a few deep breaths (or even panic).

I won’t lie; daddy-hood requires an adjustment – one not made easier by the presence of Zombie Terrorist Contractors – but it’s something that’s already added a dimension to my life (and no, that dimension isn’t soiled diapers).

Still, life moves on, though sometimes in odd, erratic ways – like when I found Wally the Wonderdog contentedly munching a still-wet brown trout in my backyard, despite the fact we live miles from the nearest trout water.

I later figured an Osprey – returning from the Mt. Shasta Hatchery – dropped the brown trout on a flyover, but to say the whole event took on a surreal cast qualifies for “Understatement of the Year.”

In the same vein, I believe the Underground laid claim to “Best Fly Fishing April Fools Post of 2009” when I fired up my “Fly Fish From Home” faux business which eliminates messy fly fishing trips, instead offering fly fishermen what they really want: A Hero Picture.

FlyFishFromHome.com

My brilliant FlyFishFromHome.com concept never received the billions in funding it deserved...

It remains a brilliant concept and an excellent example of the following: The Underground’s A Decade Ahead of the Rest of the World.

My “Dozen Best Fly Rods of All Time” post continues to draw visits (and comments), and it’s successful enough that I probably should create a followup, though I’m not all that clear what that will be.

Time passes, and these decisions are sometimes made for us.

The Underground even found itself on national television courtesy of Trout Unlimited (the other, less-famous TU).

Naturally, I caught exactly one, small fish (and looked foolish doing it), so it appears my future in television is on a par with my future with supermodels.

The Fly Fishing Stories

Naturally, we let a little fly fishing creep into the blog, including one essay on Home Waters which seemed to hit home with a lot of readers (it was one of the most linked-to posts of the year).

Fly fishing is something we engage in for reasons of fun or sanity instead of revenue or food gathering, so in other words, it’s an emotional thing, which allows us significant latitude when we talk about it.

Home waters are a state of mind – not GPS coordinates.

For example, the concept of “home water” clearly isn’t geographic in nature, but a matter of the heart.

One fly fisherman can tell another his “home waters” are literally halfway around the globe, and the second fly fisherman won’t bat an eye.

That’s because his “home waters” are a five hour drive to the north (the last ten miles on dirt roads), and while humanity is generally poor at accepting alien perspectives, fly fishermen do sometimes make worthwhile exceptions.

That’s why I tend to seek out smaller, wilder waters even though I live on a beautiful freestoner. It’s not because blueline fishing is “easy” (for the record, nothing’s easy when you’re fishing from your knees or crawling through bushes).

It’s because the fishing is – to leverage a pair of overused words – intimate and predatory at the same time, a combination I find irresistible.

In the same vein, a few other small-stream fishing reports remain my favorites of the year, including this picture-heavy fly fishing affair from early in the season.

Fly fishing a tiny Montana meadow stream

This beautiful little stream yielded a grand slam to me - and provided a resting place for a few of dad's ashes.

Then there was the small stream trip in Montana where I caught a trout grand slam on a tiny meadow stream which was – oddly enough – populated with 100 year-old freshwater mussels.

I’ve been there twice and It’s already become one of my favorite places, and because I embrace symmetry and symbolism equally, this time I left a few of my father’s ashes behind to hang out with the slow, patient mussels. It’s a perfect fit for him.

Later – as the season wound down (well, it never really winds down; the Upper Sacramento is open year-round, and in fact, I fished it yesterday), I found myself hitting a pair of local small streams, discovering the unhappy reality that trout which hurl themselves at dries in the summer don’t have much interest in doing so while winter tightens its grip.

First, on a remote water:

Lucky To Be Here

That said, I felt lucky to get what I got. In one sense, I was lucky to be there; it was sleeting when I arrived, but by noon it had grown colder, and by two, it was snowing.

When I finally left, I wondered if this was the storm that would close the road.

Even if it doesn’t, the next one might.

On the drive out, the truck skidded and slipped on dirt road, and I figured I might be the last fly fisherman to spook those trout until June or even July of next year.

Once, I entertained thoughts of skiing into this stream and fishing it long before others could get there, but the distances are daunting. And hell, I’m not even sure if the roads to the road are plowed.

Soon (very soon), the meadows will fill with snow, and they’ll stay that way for better than half the year, and the trout will go on about their lives largely untroubled – until one day the snow melts and a strange shape looms above them, waving a long, skinny stick.

If the romance of that escapes you, then check for a pulse.

Then, on the last day you actually can fish most of the small streams in my neck of the woods, I visited something nearby, and found the catching was great only if I was interested in ice-related photographs:

Small stream before winter grabs hold

The last small stream trip of the year? Almost certainly...

In other words, small streams are reviving when you want a “pure” fly fishing/predatory/wild experience, but they’re not above kicking your ass, then freezing it, then sending you home empty handed.

Good for them. Us fly fishermen are a ragged lot, prone to ego and willing to forget those moments in time when we’re not skilled or heroic, and if it takes a dumb trout living in a tiny stream to remind us, all the better.

At least we’re learning our lesson in a pretty place.

The Humor/Satire End of Things

One of the Underground’s most-viral posts was my story about the vicious, man-eating chipmunk brought into our house by a cat – a wild animal that hid under a blanket until I promptly grabbed him, thinking it was the cat, proving once again that the Underground can scream with the best of the little girls when he’s surprised.

In a less-startling vein, a couple of less-than-optimal (euphemism alert) experiences on the river left me ruminating about the kind of people you run into on a river, and why you wouldn’t necessarily want to hang out with all of them: The Top Ten Signs You Don’t Want to Fish With That Guy You Just Met

Late in the year, an Onion story got me thinking that the sport would acquire a whole new urgency if death was the result of failure (instead of a ribbing at the hands of friends).

Along the way, I managed to alienate the fly fishing industry on several fronts, including the ongoing trade show spat that’s served as one of fly fishing’s longest-running soap operas.

The Year in Pictures

It was a tough year on the picture front; my trusty Pentax Optio camera continued its slow decline, and yes, I managed to forget the thing often enough that it’s become a running joke with the L&T.

Still, I managed to scrape together a few nice pics for use on this post, and here – in no particular order – are the better pics from the Underground’s 2009 season.

I hope you enjoy them – and also hope you and yours experience a 2010 that is memorable for all the right reasons.

Big winter trout, last light.

The next two pictures were taken on my best ski-and-fly-fish trip.

If you were a trout, would you eat these?

One of my favorite pictures of 2009

Another big trout at last light. If humans had any real sense of value, trout would be worth their weight in gold

Another big trout caught at last light.

"On The Rise" TV host Frank Smethurst on the Lower McCloud - when flows rendered it almost unfishable.

Winter fly fishing on the Upper Sac isn't all BWOs; Wayne Eng nymphs up a trout

Wayne Eng caught a trout on this very drift...

The local scenery isn't bad either...

The Wonderdog remained a fan favorite, and why not?

Sometimes snow falls in black & white instead of color...

When the fly fishing's slow, the napping can be good.

Wayne Eng again, this time on Burney Creek.

An early season stonefly.

Stephen Betrand and I paid a spring visit to a small, meadow stream.

This brown trout's giving me the fin.

Sasquatch siting on a small stream.

Does he feel like a putz, or what?

Do we know all the best spots, or what?

Sometimes it's not just the trout that are pretty.

Without the hike, you're missing half the good stuff.

Weird, but we like it that way.

Mount Shasta's almost always visible around here. Lucky us...

See-through beauty...

The Underground goes all art school

This is what happens when the fly fishing's slow.

IMPORTANT NEWS UPDATE: One important 2009-related fact went unreported in my Year in Review post, and I wanted to correct it here: The Underground is proud to announce that we were one of the few organizations who did not sleep with Tiger Woods.

You may resume your normal lives.

Orvis Fishing Reports

Small Stream Reflections, And Why Fly Fisherman Sometimes NEED a Trout

September 26, 2009, by Tom Chandler 29 comments

At some points in your life, a little reflection is needed. Here’s why it should happen on a river.

The next step's a doozie.

The day before trout season opened in 1999, I ditched the Silicon Valley and moved to a tiny mountain town with its own trout river. I spent a chunk of that trout opener just sitting on the bank and watching the river go by, wondering just what the hell I’d gotten myself into.

Then, on the first day of the new millenium (1/1/2000), I fly fished Baum Lake (not much was open in the winter back then) – despite doing some things the prior evening that I did not discuss with local religious leaders.

Due to the hangover, I don’t remember a lot about that trip, but I do remember catching a fair number of Baum’s stockies on a BWO dry, which is a pretty good way to start your next 1000 years. At that point, I had no idea just what the hell I was getting myself into.

Today, I’m packing for Ethiopia, making yesterday’s trip to a small, never-fished-by-me stream – my last as a childless angler.

A couple times after I moved to Dunsmuir, I toyed with the idea of becoming a trout bum/writer/largely single guy, but never did quite pull the trigger. And frankly, I’m happy about that.

I greatly admire people like John Gierach, a man who decided to fly fish for a living and then made it happen (and does so without the posturing, false bravado, and suspiciously compensatory behavior that marks so many who take that route).

Still, admiring someone doesn’t necessarily mean following in their footsteps, and while I’m aware my new adventure represents a right turn from an earlier, more carefree existence, it’s not The End of An Era or anything remotely that dramatic.

Still, it is a moment that demands a little bank sitting, wondering just what the hell I’m getting myself into this time.

Fly fishing trips will do that to you. They force the rest of the world to recede, yet still invite you to ponder the imponderables – a neat trick for any sport.

I’m also aware that when I start thinking too deeply in the above vein, maybe it’s time to simply go fishing.

Which I did.

The Schedule = The Fishery

Due to the madness that has become life, I haven’t fished much lately, and yes, I badly needed to go despite a schedule suggesting zero tolerance for fun.

That’s why – the day before I left to start my pretty-much-around-the-world trip – I ran to a nearby small stream I’d found by accident earlier in the year, but hadn’t fly fished.

Small, pretty and almost certainly unfished.

The Wonderdog sure remembered our previous trip, and his first act – after marking every tree near the truck – was to spot the rings of a rising trout in a pool at the bottom of a small gorge.

I’d seen those rings too, but I didn’t gallump down the hill at speed and plunge headlong into the pool after the trout.

Naturally, he caught nothing, but quickly got over the disappointment after finding the bones of a recently deceased deer.

Thus, the key differences between fly fishermen and retrievers are revealed (stealth and a gag reflex).

Sure he's happy - he smells like dead deer.

I knew in advance there would be no big trout, and there was a chance there would be no trout at all.

That’s inherent in any fly fishing trip (especially one already severely constrained by distance and time), but the thought was a little punishing this time.

I hadn’t fished recently, and because this was something of a turning point in my life, I needed a trout to make the occasion. Any sized trout.

Needed one.

Just one…

Thanks. I needed that.

Deep breath.

With all the uncertainty ahead, it’s nice to know that dogs still roll in dead things, undiverted streams still flow during droughts, trout still eat dries, and fly fishermen can get their heads screwed on straight through the simple act of catching fish.

A portrait of the fly fisher as a newly young man

Working my way upstream was a challenge in stealth, casting, and yes, Wonderdog management, but I managed to land another half-dozen little trout, the biggest of which might have gone seven inches.

I didn’t care of course – this year I’ve been on a small stream jag which pretty much guarantees a dearth of “Slab of the Month” entries.

It also guarantees a slower-paced fishing experience, one which invites some odd photographic experiments, including those which find your tiny point-and-shoot camera half submerged in the water:

Why not experiment with your camera?

Or even fully submerged and looking up, trying to approximate what a handsome, local, small-stream fly fisherman might look to a trout:

Is this what trout see right before they're unhooked and released?

An hour after I started, I was finished.

Deadlines called, bags needed to be packed, people needed to be met, and I ended my last outing as a childless fly fisherman wondering if my daughter would find the same peace on small streams filled with tiny, largely ignored trout.

She’ll see plenty of running water (I’ll see to that), but will she ever find her way to a stream in the middle of a busy day, turning over stones, watching for telltale shadows on the stream bottom, rolling her eyes as her dog plunges into a fishy looking pool, and desperately wanting just one single trout – confirmation the world isn’t tilting wholly off its axis?

Cleary, the future is filled with little certainty. And a lot of possibility.

What trout see?

See you on the Stream, Tom Chandler.

The Underground Tosses a Brick Through a Plate Glass Window (or, Can You Stuff Diapers in a Patagonia Critical Mass Bag?)

September 10, 2009, by Tom Chandler 60 comments

You can probably count the number of truly life-changing decisions you’ve made on the fingers of one hand.

And no, I’m not talking about the moment you realized double-taper fly lines simply made more sense than weight forwards.

I’m talking about the lifestyle equivalent of picking up a brick and tossing it through the plate glass window that defines the limits of your neat, orderly life.

As in smashing it.

Something like that day in college when you realized words were cool things, and that perhaps you could make a living arranging them.

Or the decades-later realization that your clients had email addresses, so maybe you could hunker down near a good trout stream instead of living in the alternate universe known as the Silicon Valley.

Then there was the afternoon you realized life without a certain woman looked a lot less appealing than life with her, and maybe it was time to make this whole thing permanent.

Every one of those decisions seemed huge at the time – and each created its fair share of anxiety – but all worked out beautifully.

It appears the L&T and I have just thrown another brick.

In about two weeks, we’re saddling up a Boeing 777 jet and flying literally halfway around the world to meet our little daughter.

Our new little daughter.

Holy shit.

I’m about to become a parent.

The New Reality

I’m going to be right up front here; in the past, I have had doubts about my fitness as a parent.

And yes, since this process started a year ago, I have often huddled in bed at 3:30 in the morning, eyes wide open, mentally bulleting the ways I could emotionally (and physically) scar a kid already facing the challenges of adoption.

The good news? While adoption rules forbid me from posting her picture or name here, the pictures we’ve seen clearly indicate Little M (my clever code name) is cuter, smarter and just plain better than all the other kids on the planet.

In fact, it’s likely she’s a world-class athlete and natural-born fly caster.

I just know it.

You can tell by looking.

Plain as day.

(And yes – I already have the whole Proud Poppa thing down pat.)

Allow Me To Brag

The L&T has cleverly bypassed the “no public displays of photographs” rule by emailing Little M’s picture to approximately 80% of the planet’s working email addresses.

The overwhelming consensus is that she’s gorgeous beyond belief.

I believe they’re right.

Little M will be just over 11 months old when we bring her back home to the mountains of Northern California, where she will no doubt adapt immediately to her surroundings, sleep through the night, eat whatever she’s given, and spontaneously toilet train herself a good 12 months early.

And if she doesn’t do all those things, well, she’s still got that seriously cute thing working.

The Parent Trap

I suspect I’m not entirely alone in this, but as parent-to-be, I’m already excelling at the bit where you cycle hourly between excitement and sheer terror.

One minute I’m convinced I’m going to be a great dad, teaching my daughter all the really cool, important stuff while driving her to her next athletic triumph (track/tennis/soccer/etc – I’m easy).

The next minute I imagine falling prey to one of my absent-minded fogs, forgetting to feed my daughter, wandering off, then coming home to find her swilling drain cleaner from the bottle I left on the floor next to the gasoline-soaked rags piled on the accidentally left-on stove.

Clearly, anticipation is a two-edged sword.

Even Wally the Wonderdog knows something’s up – alerted by the steadily growing piles of kid stuff now taking over the house.

The Wonderdog’s not brilliant, but he clearly possesses an animal cunning, and he knows that diapers and brightly colored plastic toys can only mean one thing: A new source of dropped or spilled food is about to enter his life.

I have a feeling that the Wonderdog will become extraordinarily protective of Little M.

I already have.

Of course, stepping beyond the glass window that defines the limits of your “normal” life means picking up a brick and creating a little chaos.

Life changes, you sweep up the broken bits, your view is clearer and your range is expanded, and you can’t really complain.

I mean, it’s what you asked for when you picked up the brick in the first place.

See you at the glass shop, Tom Chandler.

Road to the Smokies: Hazel Creek Campout

May 7, 2007, by Tom Chandler 18 comments

Fly fishing a river tunes you into its water, bugs, and trout.

You gain a sense of the moment, hopefully catch a few trout, and walk away with what amounts to a frozen snapshot of what you think the river is all about, though most of the time we’re wrong about that.

Hazel Creek, Smoky Mountains National Park
Hazel Creek through the trees. Pretty, pretty stuff.

If fishing a river delivers a snapshot, living alongside one for a few days tunes you into much more; the animals, the weather, the river’s moods, history — even how it reacts to sun and rain.

That’s why — when Ian and Charity offered me a chance to piggyback a backpacking trip onto their outfitted trip to Hazel Creek, I jumped at it.

They (and their outfitter) ferried a group of nine anglers across Fontana Lake, where they set up camp.

A light action 8' 5wt rod and a few flies
Light action 8′ 5wt and a few flies — all that’s needed on Hazel.

Calling it a “camp” is a little misleading; they slept like royalty (cots and big tents), ate like kings (fresh-made Blackberry Cobbler, steak, shrimp kabobs, pancakes, margaritas — the list goes on), and fished like demons.

It was a lavish production, and judging by the the number of anglers who said they were ready to sign up for the next trip, the whole enterprise is bound to be repeated.

The trail up Hazel Creek. Did I mention the wildflowers?
The hike up Hazel Creek was flat, easy, and carpeted with wildflowers.

Because I’m prone to fits of isolation and self-denial, I packed my backpack with instant oatmeal and Top Ramen, and hiked five miles up the drainage.

I enjoyed being alone on Hazel Creek, but admit that being served great food while you focus on fly fishing isn’t the kind of thing I should reject out of hand.

Still, I think I made the right decision. I was hoping to lose weight, not gain it.

Hazel Creek GSMNP Overview
More Hazel Creek, farther up. Beauty, eh?

Still, there I was, five miles from the lake and setting up my ultra-lightweight “one-man” tent, which frankly felt more like a coffin.

Naturally, it started raining almost right away, and the Coffin Tent became less an abstract thought and more a temporary home.

The Coffin Tent, Hazel Creek
For the next 11 hours, this is home; the inside of the Coffin Tent.

Still, the next day (Friday) dawned wonderfully clear, so I hiked up the Bone Valley — so named because an April blizzard trapped 100 cattle in the tiny valley and killed them, leaving bones strewn everywhere.

That was in the late 1800s, so the bones are gone. What remains is a perfect little valley, complete with historic cabin (built in 1880).

Bone Valley cabin, GSMNP
The cabin in Bone Valley, which is bigger than a coffin.

The fishing was slow until 11:00, when the rainbows started hitting my dry. I don’t think fly selection was particularly important, though I believe a yellow fly improved the odds a bit (there were many yellow stoneflies flitting about).

Hazel creek rainbow trout, GSMNP
Not unlike the trout back home, except he fought with an accent.

All the fish were small, and after a couple hours, I hiked back to camp, made a late lunch, contemplated the river, and eventually headed a short ways down Hazel Creek.

It was a beautiful evening, and I was getting lots of eats on the small stimulator dry (lots of yellow stones in the air).

The fish included a couple of nice brown trout, the Tennessee version of which are so brightly colored that I marvel each time I catch one.

Hazel Creek Brown Trout
The red dots are bright, and the fins are orange. Gorgeous.

Later, I came to a large pool and didn’t get a single bite. I thought it was strange until I discovered one of Ian’s group had stuck a 26″ brown trout there only minutes before.

Oy.

Hazel Creek Water SnakeLater in the evening, I stumbled on a Sulphur hatch (with spinner fall) and managed a few more fish.

A good day. A very good day.

I also stumbled across a snake that Ian later said was harmless, though I reminded him that I could have jumped back in fear, fallen and hit my head.

Harmless my ass.

That night, it started raining again (more hours in the coffin), and the next morning the creek picked up considerable color.

Still, it was falling and clearing, and reasoning that the rain might wash the yellow stones off the leaves and into the water, I threw a small yellow stimulator.

And yes, score one for intuition.

A Toad on Hazel Creek
A frog (or toad, I can never tell which) overlooking Hazel Creek.

For a while I hammered fish — until it started raining hard. The water rose, it muddied, and the bite shut off.

Damn. I sloshed my way back to camp, and was confronted by the fact that I had nothing to do for the next 20 hours — and no dry place to do it.

By that point, the Coffin tent smelled like wet feet, which wasn’t all bad as I needed something to distract me from the wetness (and yes, next time I’m bringing a book).

One of the true joys of backpacking is when things get wet, there’s no way to make them dry until it stops raining.

And typically, everything gets wet.

The next morning, the sun came out, so rather than pack a bunch of water down the trail, I spent an hour trying to dry my gear.

Backpacking gear drying on Hazel Creek
Everything was wet, so it looks like I’m holding a wilderness garage sale.

Somehow, all the gear in the picture above fit into the pack below. (Never underestimate man’s ability stuff.)

Backpacking the Smokies
It only looks light. It’s heavy.

I hiked down the trail back to the lake — going fast and losing elevation all along the way — and encountered members of Ian’s group.

First came Charity and her client, then I stumbled on Ian fishing alone.

Ian Rutter fishing Hazel Creek
Ian Rutter pottering about on Hazel Creek.

Finally, I was at the lake, and for all intents and purposes, the trip was over.

Of course, I’m leaving out a ton of stuff, including the contents of eight pages of notes I made in a small notebook.

Rather than fall too far behind my blog posts, I’ll cover the basics here and try to write an “end of the trip” wrap-up post that will be fraught with meaning and laden with deep thoughts.

Otherwise, you’d be reading this in October.

Hazel Creek Trip Fun Fact #1

On the trip over I drank a large soft drink, then drove over “The Dragon” — a stretch of road so twisty and curvy (330+ turns in 11 miles) that motorcyclists come from miles around so they can test themselves against it. I lost the test. Even though though I was driving, I attained a state of advanced motion sickness, pulled over, and barfed on my own shoes. Nobody was more surprised than Ian.

Hazel Creek Trip Fun Fact #2

The first night in the campground I met Larry K — who owns property on the Holston River, which Ian, myself, and some Nameless Guy had floated the day before. Amazingly, he saw us go by, correctly identifying Ian’s boat, Ian, and the fact that I lost a fish right in front of his house. Ahh, Lost Fish — the ties that bind.

Larry K picture
Larry the boat watcher.

Hazel Creek Trip Fun Fact #3

Thought I took a couple of rods, I mostly fished my 8′ 5wt Diamondglass rod — a fairly flexible, slow tapered rod that was largely perfect for Upper Hazel Creek and its tribs. You want a rod able to throw big flies if needed, but soft enough to work at leader-only ranges.

Hazel Creek Trip Fun Fact #4

Hazel Creek is a fascinating area, home to a truckload of history, including logging operations that largely leveled the area, the eventual loss of those jobs, the reversion to a rural society — all of which was displaced when Fontana Lake was built and cut the area off from the rest of the world.

Some remnants remain: cabins, cemeteries, and even a rusting old iron headboard at my campsite.

Hazel Creek overview

Though I was ready to get dried out (and yeah, a warm shower wasn’t entirely outside my realm of thought), it was hard to leave Hazel, knowing it’s entirely possible I won’t make it back there again.

Hazel Creek hat

Look for a wrap-up post on my Tennessee trip (I’ve got two days of fishing yet to blog), where I plan to write more about Hazel Creek. It’s worth a few more words.

See you up the creek, Tom Chandler.

[tags]fly fishing, fishing, hazel creek, bone valley, tennessee, smokies, great smoky mountains, gsmnp, backpacking[/tags]

"When I Die, Bury Me With My Phillipson Bamboo Fly Rods." Part One.

March 20, 2007, by Tom Chandler 28 comments

Lately I’ve been looking hard at all the bamboo fly rods in my rod closet, trying to mentally define why I fish them and how I apply value to them–values that often differ markedly from the marketplace.

Then that crafty bunch over at MidCurrent went and excerpted a chapter from Casting a Spell by George Black, a book about craftsmanship and its survival in the face of the industrial revolution.

I found it interest because it paralleled my thoughts about Bill Phillipson’s fly rod company, which tells a similar story about craftsmanship in the face of growing corporatism.

From MidCurrent:

George Black’s fascination with bamboo rod-craft pivots on Eustis Edwards, whose personal history speaks volumes about the survival of craftsmanship in American culture. This excerpt looks at the final disillusioning and yet productive years of Edwards’s life, and at the rods which exemplified his obsession with perfection.

Black focuses on Edwards rods, using the rods and their makers to illustrate the changes rapidly overtaking society post WWI.

I place Bill Phillipson’s rod company in a similar context; his small, individually owned company thrived for years before it was bought in 1972 by a large corporation which–immediately and somewhat inexplicably–folded the company.

Phillipson rod picture

His bamboo trade–like most others–had foundered with the appearance of fiberglass and the bamboo embargo of the cold war years, but unlike so many other production companies, he was innovating and building what were probably the best fiberglass rods available.

I’m sure there’s an answer to be found at the bottom of a spreadsheet in a file cabinet somewhere, but it’s hardly possible to overlook the larger trend at work: the corporatization of business in the USA.

That’s why the George Black excerpt at MidCurrent dovetails so nicely with the post I was already writing in my head.

I love it when the Universe writes my lead for me.

What’s Desirable in Bamboo?

In the weird, overlapping hierarchy that defines “desirability” in modern bamboo fly rod collecting, it’s possible that the Edwards rods were among the best, least-appreciated models–at least until Black’s book was released.

Longtime bamboo rod collectors will be reminded of the release of Michael Sinclair’s “Heddon: The Rod With The Fighting Heart” book.

It had an immediate (and galvanizing) effect on the price of used Heddon rods, which–until the book’s release–crowded the used rod lists at relatively low prices.

Still, the Edwards rods were never as plentiful as the Heddons, and I know I ignored the Edwards creations simply because there weren’t enough of them available to interest me.

Yet, equally true is the fact that the rods I owned and fished weren’t really considered desirable among the majority of collectors.

If I could have afforded it, I might have made an exception for the fishable, consistently excellent Paynes, but the Garrisons, Gillums and others were too rare (and expensive) to even contemplate buying, and the time I spent with their tapers (as represented by modern builders) was underwhelming.

In my case at least, the need to “collect” simply didn’t exist, at least not in the sense that I was looking to assemble (or could afford) a quiver of rods whose makers and tapers would impress when casually dropped in bamboo-savvy company.

Bill Phillipson & His Fly Rods

When I first grew interested in older bamboo rods, I focused on the Western rods, and soon fixated on Bill Phillipson’s creations.

Phillipson was foreman of the Granger shop starting in the mid 1930s and owner the “Phillipson Rod Company” until the early 70s.

It’s likely my interest was fostered by what I learned about Phillipson himself; a sometimes gruff man, he valued function over form, and his goal was to build rods that cast and fished as well as the most expensive models, yet at a price anyone could afford.

It’s likely that tapped into the populist vein that runs through me, and clearly, Phillipson was no huckster.

He was, in fact, an expert caster and a fine fisherman, who right up until his death could be found fishing Colorado’s waters, including the South Platte.

John Gierach cops to sometimes fishing an 8.5′ Phillipson on the South Platte not just because he sometimes ran into Bill Phillipson there, but because the rod’s perfectly suited to fishing that river.

Fishing Rods, Not Toys.

If day-to-day fishability defined collectability, the Phillipsons would occupy a place on the food chain far above many more expensive rods, perhaps only one rung below the vaunted Paynes and one above the currently hot Grangers (most of which were also Bill Phillipson’s children).

Still, though I own an even dozen Phillipson rods, I never became what you’d call a “collector,” and because I like talking to rod builders, I’m wholly interested in what today’s bamboo rod craftsmen are doing in the now century-old bamboo rod trade.

Still, after years of use, a couple of my favorite Phillipsons require some ferrule work, so I need to ship them to a rod repairer (the true downside of bamboo rods).

I fish a couple of the rods often, and wonder if that means I value them so much as fishing tools that I overlook the fact that another Phillipson will never be made.

In fact, the rods fish so well, I could–in a fit of Thoreau-esque simplification–surplus all my other cane and end up a perfectly happy camper (for most trout situations anyway).

Still, let’s face it; I’m not going to do it.

What I am going to do is split this post over a couple days. So tomorrow, more on Phillipson fly rods–the models I actually like to fish.

Click to read Part II of “Bury Me With My Phillipsons.” 

See you at the rod closet, Tom Chandler.

[tags]bamboo, bamboo fly rods, phillipson, phillipson bamboo fly rods, phillipson fly rods, payne, george black, edwards bamboo fly rods, fly fishing, fly rod[/tags]

Fly Fishing as Escape: Even When it’s Bad, it’s Good.

February 24, 2007, by Tom Chandler 16 comments

I don’t know at what point putting on waders and heading to the river ceases to be a fishing trip and becomes an excuse for getting out of the house – the walls of which grow a little closer every winter day – but it’s likely I passed that point today.

It was snowing, the Upper Sacramento flows were coming back up, and Wayne agreed on the phone that we wouldn’t fish long or go far, none of which mattered.

I was getting out; not writing, computing or blogging.

I might have driven to Dunsmuir a little too fast.


Snow falling on Eng. (click the image for the big Hollywood version.)

We found ourselves fishing right in town, sharing a fly rod and a camera.

I missed the only bite of the day on a dry and dropper, which is a factually accurate summation of the trip, though it misses the point entirely.

There’s something about fishing in the snow; it’s a separate experience from fishing in sun or rain.

It’s quiet, and – if you’re dressed warmly enough – there’s the sense of functioning as a self-contained, foul-weather, mobile fishing unit.

It’s freezing outside, warm inside, and you’re pretty sure you could do this most of the day.

Still, when the fishing is tough, a couple hours is plenty to prove you’re a smart, tough fly fisher who fishes when the weather’s bad and everyone else is holed up in front of a heater.


Some days you just need to get out and marvel at the concept of waterproofing.

As I’m writing this (the end of the day), it’s snowing softly and steadily outside, and tomorrow will find me shoveling several inches of the fluffy white stuff off the driveway.

Snow is forecast for the next couple of days – good news for the ski industry – and I’ve got enough writing to do that I’ll be back in my office.

Which, suddenly, is looking a little roomier.

[tags]fly fishing, upper sac, upper sacramento river, fishing[/tags]

More Shocking Proof of Drug Abuse by Fly Fishing Writers

December 27, 2006, by Tom Chandler 21 comments

Save money tying your own flies?

That’s the hilarious contention of John McCoy (staff writer for the Charleston Gazette), and I wonder if his employer shouldn’t immediately administer a drug test – lest John suffer another drug-induced flashback.

I gaze at the piles of expensive fly tying materials, expensive hackles, machined HMH vise, chemically sharpened hooks and several-lifetimes-supply of hen necks cluttering my office and wonder what our friend John has been smoking.

fly tying vise HMH
My HMH vise. Ticket to savings, or expensive tool of obsession?

He recounts the high price of flies – and his amusing solution:

A relatively inexpensive answer to this problem is to learn to tie flies. Thirty years ago, when I started fly fishing, I couldn’t afford to buy rods and reels and flies too, so I learned to tie. I’ve done it ever since.

It’s difficult to estimate how much money I’ve saved, but I’ll try.

Let me try for you. I’d have to tie flies from now until people started making dinner reservations for their 2999 New Year’s Eve celebration to recoup the investment I’ve made in tools and materials.

And frankly, I’m an underachiever compared to the likes of Noted Pack Rat Dave Roberts, who recently built a whole new extension onto his house so he could warehouse his er…. “extensive” collection of materials.

(When the apocalypse comes and fly tying materials disappear from our nuclear-ravaged landscape, I’m heading right for Dave’s house.)

And there are plenty of people who consider him an underachiever.

So how about it? Is anyone saving money tying their own flies. Or are we spending scads of money for the privilege of getting them exactly the way we want ‘em…?

[tags]fly tying, hmh, flies, fly fishing[/tags]

Fly Fishing’s Original Blogger?

December 14, 2006, by Tom Chandler 13 comments

A few years ago, I was lucky enough to stumble across a copy of Muriel Foster’s Diary, and bought it faster than your average fly fisher buys a big fish story.

If you’re not familiar with Muriel Foster or her diary, she was an upper-class Englishwoman who lived from 1884 to 1963. In addition to fly fishing, she loved to paint, and the heavily illustrated private fishing diary she kept is an engrossing record of one woman’s love for the sport.

Muriel Foster Diary interior

She kept meticulous records of the fish she caught (including measurements and weight) as well as the flies she used.

Most pages were decorated with illustrations or poems, and the total effect is as much a portrait of the artist herself as it is a record of fishing in the early-to-mid 1900s.

Muriel Foster Diary interior2

Her diary spans a remarkable 35 years, though her latter years found her fishing (and writing) less due to the ravages of arthritis.

In fact, the final entry ends with “Finis Arthritis!” – but only after she describes fishing “a very deep, black little lake, surrounded by trees or cliff. difficult to fish.”

Like a true Undergrounder, she added “A most beautiful lake…”

There are days when I could tell you what the Trout Underground was all about, and others when I don’t have a clue, but I do know it’s at least partially an online community of like-minded fly fishing fiends/slaw dog enthusiasts – and a personal record of one writer’s fly fishing life on a river he loves.

Muriel Foster's Cover

I’d never claim to be a trout bum (and I know a few, including one who works way too hard to qualify as any sort of bum, but leads a truly enviable fly fishing life), but I do know what the sport means to a lot of the fly fishers I meet.

Most don’t keep hand-illustrated fishing diaries or snarky fly fishing blogs, but you can learn a lot from the look in their eyes when they meet you on the water, or the edge in their voice when you mention the fishing over the phone.

I only hope that – when the time comes to stop doing this (either fly fishing or the Underground, it doesn’t matter which) that I go with the grace of Muriel Foster, who didn’t make a big deal about things, but allowed as to how she’d fished a beautiful, deep black little lake with a borrowed rod.

Muriel Foster Diary interior3

Note: there are still used copies of Muriel Foster’s Fishing Diary floating around the Internet, including a few here at Amazon.com: Muriel Foster’s Fishing Diary (A Studio book)
[tags]muriel foster, diary, fly fishing[/tags]

Winter’s Here.

November 28, 2006, by Tom Chandler 7 comments

When your back is sore from shoveling snow and your last walk with Wally the Wonderdog found you plowing through five inches of powder snow (the Wonderdog loves snow – he’s a powder pup for sure), then you can say that winter’s officially arrived.

Mount Shasta Winter photo
A walk with the Wonderdog. Photo by Tom. Snow & sunset colors by God.

For many, it’s time to settle in and start tying flies, but ever since the Upper Sacramento was opened to year-round fishing, my fly boxes have slowly emptied.

It’s a busy week, but fishing is hardly out of the question. More snow coming today. More clouds later this week. And more to come on the Underground!

[tags]winter, upper sacramento river, mount shasta[/tags]

Another Underground Grand Slam: Let the Gloating Begin

November 19, 2006, by Tom Chandler 8 comments

Given that 98% of the time you spend fly fishing could be technically classified as a failure, then having expectations for the remaining 2% seems pretty far fetched.

So it’s probably accurate to say that going fly fishing with a lot of expectations in place simply means you think you know what’s about to happen before something else does.

After today, I’m all for spontaneity.

Upper Sacramento River brown trout
Wayne Eng holding my 19″ brown. Big browns are our friends.

Surprise!

Earlier this year I scored an Upper Sacramento River Grand Slam; browns, brookies and rainbows in one evening.

I would have laid odds on it being the last time it would happen, but – based on the photographic evidence below – I was dead wrong.

Sometimes it’s good to be dead wrong.

Dazed and Confused.

Wayne Eng and I headed to a part of the river I swore I’d fished in the past, but now realize I hadn’t. It was long ago and my only excuse is that I was younger and generally more confused back then.

I’m glad I finally made it.

Waiting for me was a 19″ brown trout who ate a #16 dry. And a pair of 12″ Brookies who ate #16 dries. And several colorful rainbows who ate #16 dries.

The Grand Slam. And you get to read all about it for free.

Upper Sacramento River brown trout closeup
A closeup of our friend the 19″ Brown trout. He’s Brown-a-licious.

Upper Sacramento River brookie
I love Brookies. They’re Brook-a-licious.

Upper Sacramento River Rainbow trout
The rainbows here are beacons. They’re Bow-a-licious.

It’s tempting to wax philosophical about the whole affair as if you and I were sitting in the study wearing smoking jackets and drinking $100-a-bottle liqueur.

Instead, it was just normal fishing, even down to the Keystone Cops moment that erupted when the 19″ brown – which I initially thought was small – took off for Lake Siskiyou.

I needed to scramble over a couple of car-sized rocks to land him, and while I’d like to think I did so with aplomb and grace, an honest appraisal would probably include words like “elephantine” and “clod.”

Fine. You hook a big brown and see how many octaves your voice goes up.

I landed the fish, and Wayne even stopped laughing long enough to help, the sign of a good friend or a fisherman with priorities.

Upper Sacramento River Wayne Eng
Wayne Eng fishing a dry. It’s Sac-a-licious.

As for the death of expectation, not only was I wrong about fishing that stretch before, but we set out thinking we’d score heavy with the spent October Caddis dry.

Naturally, we did better with a #16 yellow stone and a similar-sized olive parachute.

I was fishing an 8′ 5wt Steffen Brothers glass rod that Rich Margiotta built for me, and it was lovely.

Wayne said it cast like it was on ball bearings – a better description than I would have written – and I’m slowly building a case for the concept that low-modulus materials fight fish better.

I’ll let you know after a couple more years of testing.

The L&T Nancy and I are heading south for Thanksgiving (to a place tragically devoid of trout) so there’s little hope for another fishing report for a week or so.

Of course, that won’t necessarily stop me from posting. Or wishing I was fishing. See you on I-5, Tom Chandler.

[tags]rainbow trout, brook trout, brown trout[/tags]

123

Paying the Bills

Allen Fly Fishing

Follow us

FacebookTwitterRSS feed

Recent comments

  • Phil: Ha! kinda cool... there is another firm out in the...
  • Mark + Wiz: My laptop screen broke so i saw it on a...
  • Tom Chandler: And here I thought it was a coincidence that some...
  • Steve Z: Umm, hello?! Those are contrails from the Sasquatch's spaceships. Nice...
  • Carp Fishing: wow what a nice picture. After a long time I...
  • Tom Chandler: I think they're feeding our hatchery trout some kind of...

What I Said

  • Mt. Shasta SunriseOops, Just Found This Mt. Shasta Sunrise On The Camera
  • Bamboo smartphonesThe Bamboo Underground, The Smartphone Edition
  • Mammoth Learns What LA’s Water Thirst Feels Like
  • Pecan crusted troutHot Recipe For Those Hatchery Steelhead: Pan Seared, Pecan-Encrusted Trout
  • the MermaidWe Do Carp Like Nobody Else Does Carp

Short Casts

  • Two frogs gain EPA status in California, could affect some alpine fisheries: http://t.co/jHtUFLo2 15 hrs ago
  • World Championship of Spey Casting at Golden Gate Casting Club on 4/20-4/22 (Jimmy Green Spey-O-Rama): http://t.co/tzTlUVwE 20 hrs ago
  • RT @matt_weiser: Draft report on raising #Shasta Dam released by @usbr. http://t.co/myKkRUoa #cawater #fishing #salmon 20 hrs ago
  • Good news for Eagle Lake Trout: BLM Closes Bypass Pipe in Eagle Lake Bly Tunnel Plug: http://t.co/ch5vjSwY 21 hrs ago
  • The Fly Fishing Film Tour (F3T) pops up in Marin on March 20 (via CalTrout and Leland's). Click to avoid ennui and madness:... 4 days ago
  • More on the Bitteroot River/Mitchell Slough riverbed alterations we mentioned the other day: http://t.co/pd1O4ZwO 4 days ago
  • More updates...

Powered by Twitter Tools

RSS Singlebarbed’s Crazy, But…

  • But everyone has a firm handshake and wide white-toothed smile
  • Fly Fishermen, there’s one born every minute
  • The dreaded simple housekeeping post
  • Remember, everytime you drink POM Wonderful a Kitten dies

RSS California Trout

  • A River At A Crossroads: The Case For Klamath Dam Removal
  • The Art of Deception Fly Fishing Exhibit Debuts At Turtle Bay (Redding, CA)
  • The Fly Fishing Film Tour, CalTrout Style (Tickets Available Now for Marin Showing)
  • The Klamath Dam Removal Legislation: “The time for Congress to act is now”

RSS My Writing blog

  • Living & Writing In The Mountains
  • Weekly Tweetfest
  • Ridley Scott And YouTube Partner On A Film Festival
  • Are Tablet Computers Right For Writers?

Categories

Random Acts of Advertising

We Disclaim

The opinions expressed on the Underground don't reflect the views of my clients, friends, or even people I meet at the Post Office. I'm sure I can be bought, just not at today's prices.

Runs On

Ubuntu Linux OS
WordPress

Reading List

Recent Reading

Ready Player One
Prayers on the Wind
In the Beginning...was the Command Line
Frankensteins and Foreign Devils
Robert B. Parker's Killing the Blues
Fever Pitch
High Fidelity
Reamde
Where the Hell Am I? Trips I Have Survived
Moneyball: The Art of Winning an Unfair Game
On Writing Well: The Classic Guide to Writing Nonfiction
Juliet, Naked
Your Idea Machine
Days of Atonement
Hush Money
Writing the Pilot
The Nasty Little Writing Book : Longtime New York Publishing Insider Reveals Secrets Only Best-Selling Authors Know
The Writing Life
The Wave: In Pursuit of the Rogues, Freaks, and Giants of the Ocean
Bass Wars: A Story of Fishing Fame and Fortune


Tom Chandler's favorite books »
}

Tags

affta bamboo fly rod bamboo fly rods bottled water brown trout california water wars caltrout fiberglass fly rod fishing Fishing Report Fly Fishing fly fishing gear fly fishing industry fly fishing montana fly fishing small streams fly fishing the upper sacramento fly fishing the upper sacramento river fly fishing video fly rod fly rods Fly Tying invasive species john gierach Klamath River maine mccloud mccloud river montana Nestle october caddis orvis outdoors rainbow trout Road Trip salmon recovery singlebarbed steelhead ted williams trout trout underground trout unlimited upper sac Upper Sacramento upper sacramento river wally the wonderdog
Copyright © 2011 The Trout Underground. All Rights Reserved, so you kids better get off my lawn.