cantara loop spill,    Environment,    News,    upper sacramento river

As We Near 20th Anniversary of Cantara Loop Spill, What's Happening on the Upper Sacramento River?

By Tom Chandler 5/12/2011

It's been nearly twenty years since a train derailed on the Upper Sacramento River's Cantara Loop, dropping a tanker of metam sodium into the river.

On June 4, 1991, fishermen and residents of the area saw nearly 40 miles of the Upper Sacramento River essentially sterilized, and oddly enough, we were probably lucky it was metam sodium and not something more persistent.

Luck, I guess, is relative.

An ABC TV news team did a story about the anniversary (which I'd forgotten), and if you look hard, you'll notice Wayne Eng's backside (probably his better side) several times in the footage.

Also, CalTrout's Curtis Knight makes an appearance.



Since the spill, Union Pacific has replaced the wooden ties in the canyon with concrete, built that monstrous super trestle, and now uses "pusher" engines to reduce the strains on the cars in the middle of trains (which are the most likely to derail).

Still, a 2003 derailment in the Upper Sacramento River Canyon saw a tanker of hydrochloric acid come off the tracks within spitting distance (literally) of the river, suggesting that the safety of the river is largely an illusion.

So while UP has taken steps, it still could improve the way it builds the trains headed up and down the canyon (the spill was caused -- in part -- by empty cars in the middle of the train, which can be more easily pulled off the tracks when loaded cars are attached to the front and back of the train).

More derailments are inevitable. What they mean to the river so many of us have come to love as our own? That one's largely up to lady luck.

See you holding my breath every time a train passes through the canyon, Tom Chandler.

AuthorPicture

Tom Chandler

As the author of the decade leading fly fishing blog Trout Underground, Tom believes that fishing is not about measuring the experience but instead of about having fun. As a staunch environmentalist, he brings to the Yobi Community thought leadership on environmental and access issues facing us today.

A better solution would be to re open SP's old Modoc Line thru Alturas and route all hazmat loads through that route. Or use track-age rights over BNSF to feather river canyon
0
0
The regulations changed after the spill, and two things were astonishing: 1) How good the fishing was when the closure ended 2) How much better wild fish management can make a river We still have the catch & keep/stocked section in the middle of the river, but overall, it was a big improvement. I wasn't around for the fighting, but I heard stories about the factionalization in Dunsmuir; some people ... more were hot to back hatchery trucks up to the river and get it going right away, but a group of locals fought for letting it re-seed from the naturally.
0
0
As shocking and avoidable as the spill was, my experience has been that the river is a vastly better fishery than beforehand. Pre-spill I recall catching identical planters, though consistently. Post-spill without the planing and years of catch and release management, I catch larger fish, most of which I assume are stream bred.
0
0
Probably what used to be the "Old Grand Dad" distillery, wich, if memory serves me correctly, was located in very close proximity to the forks of the Elkhorn, which is where my dad learned how to swim lotsa years ago.
0
0
That's interesting, I didn't realize that was a cause of train derailments. We had a similar spill here in Kentucky on Elkhorn Creek, which is one of our prime smallie habitats, about a decade ago. However, the source of this spill was different. Alcohol spilled from a whiskey plant annihilated the food chain from top to bottom and it took years for it to bounce back to what it was. Unfortunately ... more this is a way of life for us fishermen. I would like to say we could do without those things that might harm the environment, but I'm not sure I can give up on my Jim Beam.
0
0
Thought of writing a story of the "Wreck of the ol' 97" until I realized how much research was involved, how many different facts. Definitely not a short story. Wait...maybe it is. Can't make up my mind. It just looks like a lot of work, and I'm trying to avoid that these days, since no one will pay for it, and it would cut into the fishing.
0
0

Discover Your Own Fishing and Hunting Adventures

With top destinations, guided trips, outfitters and guides, and river reports, you have everything you need.