The New York Times published an insightful profile of Underground Fav Writer Thomas McGuane, whose new novel (Driving on the Rim) has just been released.
McGuane’s known among fly fishermen for his liberal application of fly fishing scenes in his novels, but also for The Longest Silence; his seminal collection of fly fishing essays that many feel define the sport better than any other single book (“book on tape” version here).
McGuane’s latest novel will no doubt find its way to the Underground’s bookshelf, but Charles McGrath’s insightful profile included this rather charged McGuane quote:
“Like everyone, I have that general sense that we’ve been cast adrift. It’s almost banal to say it, it’s so obvious. But at the same time, living out here I have sense that I’m living in a world that hasn’t quite changed. I see it in some of the kids who work here — they’re still so in touch with natural world.â€
These days there are plenty of good writers practicing the art, and yet McGuane continues to deliver single-sentence insights that rock me back on my heels.
A year ago I suggested our lives changed when a brick got tossed through the plate glass windows that contain our existence, and that nowadays, the bricks were coming with increasing regularity.
It’s a theme that apparently plays out in Driving on the Rim:
But like much of Mr. McGuane’s recent writing, it’s also partly about the collision of the Old West and the New. Dr. Pickett finds himself involved in a very contemporary malpractice prosecution but also spends a lot of time hunting and fishing and thinking about the old days.
Fly fishermen have long described their sport as an escape from everyday life; should we add the concept of fly fishing as an anchor against the changes washing over us with increasing frequency?
See you in the bookshelves, Tom Chandler.






























Thanks for posting a link to the actual NYT article, MidC.com missed it and just published links to Amzonn books, but its all good.
Ethan Smith(Quote)
Must be that journalism training kicking in. As for the links to book sources, that’s something that’s probably worth exploring.
Do I link book titles to Amazon – which offers good prices to my readers? Or do I link to an independent bookseller (as in this case) thinking that we need the indies to keep the giants like Amazon (who was clearly throwing their weight around in the ebook arena) in check?
Tom Chandler(Quote)
BTW – just added a link to your blog in the sidebar. Wonder how I missed it for so long…
Tom Chandler(Quote)
Wow …. anchor against a changing world …. sums up like nothing I’ve ever read why I prefer to pursue fly fishing the way I do….. the “new” stuff I like is mostly the things like cortland peach that haven’t changed much in many years…..the tackle and the tying and the fishing are an anchor or a seawall separate part of life from the bberry, cell, laptop, work, market……… that raging current of change and technology washing over me every day
Well said Tom!!!!!
Marty(Quote)
It seems the older you get, the more comfort you take in doing certain things the way they’ve always been done (as far as you know).
I’ve been fishing all my life, but only with the fly for a couple years. One thing I’ve picked up on that I think helps distinguish the fly fisherman is his affection for process. Process is very, very important to fly fishermen. The idea that a given process has existed for a long time in a state of near perfection, and that by executing said process in that way somehow connects you with everyone else who’s done it that way…that has a lot of appeal.
Evolution permeates all things, though, even the things that slouch in the dusty corners of the world like fly fishing. On the other hand, it is nice to allow yourself to imagine that perhaps the forces of evolution, innovation, and improvement are not quite so restless on the river as they are elsewhere.
MHH(Quote)
I hadn’t thought of it in those terms. It’s a very interesting idea, though given my stance towards humanity in general, I’m not sure if the value of that connection is as real for some of us as others.
This was exactly what I was getting at. It’s not that fly fishing doesn’t change, it’s that it changes at a glacial pace compared to much of the rest of the world (except perhaps GM).
Tom Chandler(Quote)
Come on down to Sacramento on November third and ask him in person. He’s speaking at the Crest Theater a block from the Capitol, though tickets are a steep (to me) $30.
http://www.californialectures.org/mcguane.html
Kevin(Quote)
Thanks for the notice. Given the string of deadlines facing me (right up until the 7th), I think I’ll have to pass. Recently had to pass on Garrison Keillor in Redding too…
Tom Chandler(Quote)
Tom/Readers -
Is it possible that we are consumed with the thought that fly fishing sets us apart in some way and has a deeper meaning? We sometime seem to struggle with why or at least we attempt to always explain why. It’s always been this way with fly fisherman. We’ve been the butt of jokes in the “regular” fisherman world for ages because of our eccentric behavior and devotion. We’ve felt the need to explain ourselves I guess or at least seek camaraderie in a most personal pursuit.
As always we seem to be possessed to define why we enjoy standing in the river. It is the river after all that makes us realize we have no control of something and it’s in that environment we summon our intellect to trick a fish who we share the environment with.
As time passes we become accustomed to the rivers forces and find comfort in the flow of things. But it is always the river that defines us I think. One thing I’ve found true, all fly fisherman love rivers.
I’m an old man, no doubt about that, my children and grand & great grand children will confirm it. I find the internet mysterious. I guess that blogs have enabled us to express ourselves in many ways and also explore the mystery of why we enjoy stuff too. It’s a way to anomalously explore just why the heck we do some things. Like why do we enjoy fly fishing? What is it? I’ve been doing it for nearly 60 years and until I began reading blogs, I never knew it was a meaningful question, I never questioned it. It just was something I enjoyed doing.
I appreciate and enjoy the passion and humanity that Tom has brought to this blog and the readers who have contributed are no less worthy of praise for their devotion, contributions and stewardship of our wild places. Thank heavens for fly fisherman, in that we wish to leave the natural things alone, but not without agenda, because it is central to our existence and our place to escape. Escape.
Do we want/need to know all the answers? Isn’t fly fishing and the river in itself the answer?
My grandfather and father planted me next to a riffle when I was less than 9 years old, I fished with them for 20 years. We never questioned and/or pondered why we fished, it wasn’t a matter of why, it just something we loved to do, together. The river was always central to our life and it brought us together like no other force of nature could.
I read somewhere that “the tug is the drug”. When I first read that I chuckled because but of course it is true, that is an incurable addiction. But regardless if you get a tug or a smug, isn’t it great to be in the river?
Gary(Quote)