Those of us who lovingly caress our big-dollar fly rods – secure in the knowledge that they offer us absolute tactical ascendancy (if not moral supremacy) on the river – will be pleased to know that a North American fly fishing record pike was just caught… on a $21 5wt:
About a month ago, Ivan Keeney decided to take up fly fishing. He bought a $21 fly rod and learned to cast at Dry Bridge Family Fishing Pond in Kalispell, catching stocked rainbow trout. Once he felt that he was proficient at fly fishing, he decided to try for pike.
The beginning fly-caster cemented his place at the upper reaches of the sport today when he landed a 47-inch, 29.7 pound pike at Smith Lake west of Kalispell.
Just to further grind the noses of the sport’s literary fiends, he had his catch certified at the “Snappys Sport Senter” [sic].
Frankly, I didn’t know you could buy a fly rod for $21 (I think you can buy a bright yellow Eagle Claw fiberglass at Rite Aid for $28, but you’re probably just paying for the name at that point).
At this point, our advice to Keeney is simple.
Quit.
It’s unlikely he’s ever going to top a four-foot long pike, meaning he’s likely peaked in the sport – after only one month. That’s a burden you simply don’t want to carry decade after decade.
See you at Snappys Sport “Senter,” Tom Chandler.






























Hope he sticks with it. There are harder fish to catch than pike, and an encouraging experience like this should give him a reservoir of confidence that other finny friends will drain rapidly.
Philip(Quote)
‘Frankly, I didn’t know you could buy a fly rod for $21 (I think you can buy a bright yellow Eagle Claw fiberglass at Rite Aid for $28, but you’re probably just paying for the name at that point).’
LOL
SBW
suburban bushwacker(Quote)
Yeah, I really don’t think the fish give a rip what kind of rod is used. Fancy gear is merely to satisfy the fisherman, not the fish.
Michelle(Quote)
Hell, that’s nothing.
Almost everytime I go out with my $49.99 Cabela’s combo fly rod & reel I hook a 195-pounder.
Problem is, usually it’s some asshole I foul-hook.
(Yes, mine.)
A. Wannabe Travelwriter(Quote)
I bought a 4 weight glass Shimano fly rod and a yellow glass Eagle Claw at “Wallyworld” for $15.95 each (on sale)- I needed loaner rods for guests…( I also don’t usually shop Walmart, but I had an electrical job there…)
Brett From Utah(Quote)
I fished for years with an old glass rod that set me back about ten bucks — don’t even remember the brand anymore. Biggest thing I ever hooked was my old half-ton Chevy.
pj finn(Quote)
I don’t know undergrounder’s what more impressive, landing a 47†fish with high-end $1500 equipment or some low end junk.
I mean this guy did manage to land a 29+ Lbs fish with a low end rod (very low end). Not to mention I’m sure the real was not milled from some all aircraft aluminum, space age material with a drag system that could stop a 1950 Jeep Willys running down hill.
We need to give this guy some credit. Too bad he was most likely in a boat, I would like know if he is felt or rubber soled guy…
Snowfly(Quote)
To be honest I don’t get it… So what if he had cheap equipment? You don’t need to spend thousands of dollars on you equips to be a good fisherman. All you need is a little knowledge and some luck.
Milos Lazarevic(Quote)
Having put out there that I bought”junk” rods, I feel OK about defending pricier equipment too- sometimes quality matters- and for some things quality does cost- and I’ll gladly pay for something that works – But, I don’t want to be a sucker either…
Brett From Utah(Quote)