I understand the concept of luxury establishments just fine, and even if I didn’t, I largely lack the class warrior gene. If the rich want to pay through the nose to catch pellet-fed trout, then more power to ‘em.
Still, when Donnie Beaver enters into the equation – the much-disliked “entrepreneur” who has repeatedly tried to illegally bar public access to public waters – then I’m also completely willing to howl at the moon a little.
It appears Beaver’s (Ward, I’m concerned about the Beaver) westward expansion has resulted in a the HomeWaters Club (Official Motto: Never Again Be Forced to Fly Fish With Common People).
This from the “Luxist” web site:
HomeWaters Club is a theme based private club, with multiple locations and reciprocal rights of use in each, similar to an equity-based destination club, but with a fly-fishing identity. It was formed in 2009 as an alliance between Spring Ridge Club of Pennsylvania and Alpine River Club of Colorado, to preserve, and offer members access to 35 miles of trout and steelhead waters across Pennsylvania and 40 miles of the streams and rivers in Colorado. At present, there are nearly 200 members, and the club is expanding to other areas of the US. But right now, the locations span from central, northeastern and Erie, Pennsylvania, to Vail and Steamboat Springs Colorado areas.
So far, it’s pretty standard marketing puffery, albeit for a company whose bylaws include a hoofprint signature from the cloven-hooved deceiver himself.
But in the next paragraph, note the appearance of a well-known fly fisherman’s name:
Recently, a new dimension was added to HomeWaters Club, and that is is HomeWaters University. This is a new program designed to offer a two-day fly-fishing immersion experience. With a staff of 20 fishing guides, HomeWaters University can teach beginners and experts, children and parents, from how to cast for the first time, all the way to learning new casting skills. Housed at the HomeWaters Club new River Village in Spruce Creek, Pennsylvania, the center-piece of HomeWaters University is the first-ever Lefty Kreh Challenge Course offering a range of dry-land, still-water and moving-water stations.
Ahh, Lefty – fly fishing’s Biggest Self-Promoter Most Recognized Name. Did you really have to do it?
Clearly, fly fishing isn’t a route to a lifetime of riches or early, yacht-based retirement.
That said, you risk being exposed for feet of clay when you mess with the folks drawing the attention of a lot of airborne rotting vegetables.
See you on the river, Tom Chandler.






























Ahh, Lefty. Last week pimping for Tennesee, this week it’s, well, whatever place is paying him right now. Oh, Lefty, should I spend 25 large and go to Spruce Creek or out west? To which Lefty replies, “ “I told him not to go out west and said he should go to [Tennesee] [Spruce Creek] [where ever I am right now]. There’s better fly fishing down there [up there, over there, somwhere] for trout than there is out west now.†What a tool.
Craig(Quote)
For $88K or whatever, the fishing really should be better….
Tom Chandler(Quote)
Most of the guys that have $88K to plop down on a membership for some fly fishing anything probably won’t live long enough to see a real ROI on that investment. Just say’n.
Bjorn(Quote)
This issue should be referred to the Trout Underground’s Special Covert Operations division.
Publish the names and addresses of these wind knots in TU’s “We Know Where You Live” directory. Also, a memo to TFO’s Rick Pope, expressing a concern for a spokesperson who would promote private waters, and maybe, just maybe, that same spokesperson, for the same reason, may just endorse foreign fly rods.
Turnip Truck Driver(Quote)
another rub from the pimple on the ass of humanity.Now we have to irritations to cause us to walk diffferent…please Lord if you have a sence of humor allow Mr. Buttbreath to meet me on a river bank.
samistopdog(Quote)
Aw, hell, Lefty’s gotta eat too. These kinds of clubs serve a good purpose, since they keep a bunch of witless clods off of our rivers; not unlike the”game farms” where the unskilled and clueless can be kept amused without endangering the rest of us. They also probably help the equipment makers.
Philip(Quote)
Gotta admire this approach to an irritating subject. You win the Underground’s “glass half full” award.
As for the game farms, you may have a point, though if you’ve ever been at a shooting range during the fall “tune-up” period for all the once-a-year deer hunters, you’d know there’s plenty of people out there wholly capable of endangering the rest of us – including a couple who literally couldn’t hit the side of a refrigerator box at 100 yards…
Tom Chandler(Quote)
I’m with Philip, but it gets even better. Any guide knows that you’ll meet these folks sooner or later. They appear in your boat honed and ready to rock, with their diploma from Home Waters U (and a nice embroidered polo, too). If they are the effusive type they’ll wax on about the top-flight preparation and experience they’ve had. Then they’ll proceed to suck because they’ve met nothing but tame fish and manicured water, having been quarantined from the real world. Oh, the hilarity.
And you’d think they’d get a copywriter for all that jack. That’s pretty turgid stuff for a high-end outfit. Let’s hope they hired better trout-polishers and grasshopper-droppers for the actual fishing part.
Dave
davem(Quote)
I gotta say, the copy unimpressed almost as much as Lefty’s reappearance in a Beaver endeavor.
And they probably did get a copywriter… right off elance….
Tom Chandler(Quote)
The concerning bit for me is the fact that they’ve been able to rope off 75 miles of water in 10 years. They now have 200 self righteous pricks with nothing better to do with their deep coffers than blow it on exclusive rights to the trout chow arenas and expanding their evil empire.
I hear the BS argument a lot that “they’re posting land that always was private anyway”. What people have to realize is that there are people who seek out remote trout streams on private land and then work with the landowner to get permission to fish on their property. This means fixing fences, bailing hay, cleaning up around the place or dropping off a fresh apple pie once in a while. With this group competing in that playing field, we can’t win. The more access they buy and lease, the less chance any of us have of ever finding a mutually beneficial landowner/flyfisherman relationship.
The homewaters website openly lists a large number of their followers, and I would urge anyone who feels strongly about this to review those names and in some cases companies to avoid helping them in any way. Two of their long time supporters are Barry and Cathy Beck. Unfortunately, TU features some of their photographs in their calendar. I tore their photo out and burned it to get my grill started.
Sorry for posting on an old post. I’ve just been revisiting this issue lately and came across this post.
ASRCC(Quote)
My beef with the Beavers has always been their tendency to illegally fence off water, something which has happened several times.
That so many high-profile folks are happy to support that kind of behavior is interesting, to say the least…
Tom Chandler(Quote)