Can fly fisherman really survive for long in a the “regular” world – an unnatural habitat where fashion still exists and people sometimes dress in other than rubber pants and vented shirts?
Tomorrow morning, our little family leaves for a weekend at a secret location: a place where it’s warm, there are no trout (save those found in plastic wrap), and yes – there is a dress code.
A “resort casual” dress code.

Uh, is this Resort Casual? Because really, I'm lost here.
Sure, I’m an award-winning copywriter, a top fly fishing blogger and the investigative genius behind this Pulitzer-winning* expose of fly fishing’s effect on the fashion industry, yet despite my humble nature, I truly have no idea what “resort casual” looks like.
After all, I’m the guy who decided to take the guesswork out of getting dressed every morning by ordering a dozen army surplus t-shirts in (Coyote Tan & Olive Drab) and four pairs of Dickies work jeans, and simply wearing those every day.
Einstein figured wearing the same suit every day removed one more distraction from his brain, and given the generally low wattage powering me these days, one less decision sounds pretty good.
If it’s good enough for one of mankind’s greatest minds, then it’s good enough for me.
But I hadn’t counted on those cursed words: “Resort Casual.”
Compounding the problem is this: not since tweed jackets and wicker creels were the norm have fly fishermen been accused of being natty dressers. In fact, a careful analysis of fly fishing’s photo stream forces a rather different conclusion.
Unless pastel or earth-tone vented shirts – fully equipped with floatant stains and the oily remnants of lunch – are now considered haute couture, fly fishermen look to be largely slobs.
I won’t pretend I’m better than the rest of fly fishing (in this one instance), though I don’t often wear vented shirts differentiating myself from the rest of the herd and increasing my profile among the hordes of groupies crowding the rivers and fly shops.
In truth, I’d come to believe that living in the shadow of Mt. Shasta – a mountain big enough to house an entire race of aliens (the lemurians) – protected me from the dangerous trend rays which contaminate less-shielded urban folks.
And frankly, I was happy with the situation (army surplus t-shirts are only 3 for $15), but have now come face to face with “Resort Casual.”
I’m lost.
And in a fit of public service, I’m going to help the Undergrounders avoid my sorry fate.
First, must I point out this mess is the byproduct of a non-fly fishing related trip?
I didn’t think so.
Which leads us to Important Fly Fishing Rule For Dealing With The Rest of the World Which Doesn’t Fly Fish #7:
#7: Never, ever leave home unless fly rods are involved. (Or the shooting range. Or a trail. Or some other dirt-related activity.)
We’ll go over the rest of the rules when I get back.
See you rummaging through my closet, Tom Chandler.
(*Not a Pulitzer winner)






























… ditto -(except for the Mt. Shasta part).
Buffalo Country(Quote)
Interesting- Filson meets Wall Street with a little Peewee Herman thrown in. I would defiantly not ware this ode to “spring on the Mad†in your neck of the woods Tom; as I recall the Cletus’ boys shoot at folks in Lycra…
Snowfly(Quote)
“And don’t forget – Friday is Hawaiian shirt day, campers.”
Smithhammer(Quote)
Three comments, and no one has revealed the meaning of “resort casual?”
I’m starting to think the Undergrounders are the bohemians everyone else says they are…
Tom Chandler(Quote)
I have seen that same outfit in the back of your Bronco! Granted, it was in ecru, but there it was. Teasing us with wanting to know what “resort casual” means. You silly boy.
Chris Raine(Quote)
Liar. That hat was yours.
Tom Chandler(Quote)
I don’t know about elsewhere, but here “resort casual” means that you don’t have to wear a tie with your bib overalls, and the girls have to leave their mudders at the door and wear a full compliment of underwear.
JJP(Quote)
Oh, Yeah. I bow to the depth, length and breadth of your research on this important subject!
JJP(Quote)
Well, In Maine resort casual usually means a mid-weight flannel and some clean, non-cargo carhartt pants or shorts. Hat WITHOUT flies stuck in it. If you ask my mother or lady friend, it means you have to shave as well. (bullshit)
And of course, don’t forget the boat shoes or loafers.
MaineFlyBoi(Quote)
It’s not that hard….From ehow.com!
…Men’s Daytime Resort Casual
A gentleman’s resort casual look for day tends to consist of a classic polo shirt or other collared top. Jackets, with the exception of denim, are appropriate for layering, as are knits and pullovers, as long as they are classy and presentable. A non-denim bottom, such as khakis, linen pants or chinos are approved bottoms. Men’s flat shoes are the best footwear, worn with matching socks to correspond with footwear, which is brown or black. Boat shoes and loafers are a classic choice; finish off the outfit by adding a watch.
Men’s Evening Resort Casual
For evening, men’s resort casual dress is often a day outfit transitioned. Adding a jacket to the look and changing from shorts to slacks can easily accomplish the outfit. Hats are not to be worn, but men’s jewelry such as watches are an acceptable addition. Keep the look simple and classic, with no denim or T-shirts. White socks should never be worn in evening wear, and black socks work well with a gentleman’s loafer or other dress casual shoe….
Hope I’ve helped. (although I disagree about linen pants – they wrinkle rather easily)
John(Quote)
That is truly awe-inspiring research, though sadly, I own almost none of the items listed.
And it appears that – as I have the chance to look around – that trophy wives are accepted attire, as are graying temples.
Tom Chandler(Quote)
Once again your hard hitting journalism has left me speechless; maybe that’s a good thing…
Kentucky Jim(Quote)
You gave that hat to me as a present. You bitch.
Chris Raine(Quote)
When I get home from a hard day at the office and put on my shorts and t-shirt and grab a cold one, you might say I resort to causal.
A. Wannabe Travelwriter(Quote)
Isn’t that more “resorting to alcoholism”?
Tom Chandler(Quote)
I’ve arrived (in the travel, not financial, sense), and discovered that one doesn’t exactly wear the same dickies carpenter pants that he travels in to dinner – at least not if he wants to avoid the steely glare of the host.
Still, it turns out the Underground’s focus on clothing was misplaced – at this place, it appears “Resort Casual” really involves older guys “wearing” much younger women.
Who knew?
And how many fly fishers (save flyfishmagazine’s murdoch) aspire to trophy wives? At least the L&T feels at home with her trophy husband (see what I did there) on her arm…
Tom Chandler(Quote)
Darn you’re good. This whole thread will be invaluable the next time I come off the beach, or head for Pennsylvania or the Adirondacks.
JJP(Quote)
It’s all about service here at the Underground; if we can help our readers fit in to polite society like we actually belong there (a sham), we’ve helped.
And the giving never stops here…
Tom Chandler(Quote)
The fashion industry sure comes up with some silly stuff. I know that’s the point but it’s often still hard to swallow.
Ernest(Quote)