The bugs had just started and a few trout were rising, and it was suddenly very clear I’d spent most of my summer fly fishing small streams.

Well, somebody caught something. It just wasn't me...
Fishing a small stream is gratifying, but it’s not the best preparation for throwing #22 emergers at very spooky trout – which tend to stop rising whenever you wade closer than 35′.
In other words, I was rusty.
Rusty enough that I got a little cranky with myself on the water.
That’s a bad thing, because when I’m cranky, I start cataloging my fly fishing failures, and under the impetus of an admittedly self-critical nature, that list can grow very long.
Wrong flies. Out of 6x. Every cast eight inches short. Not sneaky enough. Not piling enough tippet for a good drift. Not focused. Bad karma from prior lifetime.
It can get a little weighty at a moment in your life when a little confidence is a real asset.
The Code
Sometimes, you never do crack the code, and the bugs stop appearing and the fish stop rising, and you stand hip-deep in seriously freezing cold water and wonder why you took up this sport in the first place.
Other times you change one simple thing: tippet, fly, more reach in the cast – and the whole experience resolves itself right in front of your eyes, and the trout do their part by eating the fly.
It’s either the way things are supposed to work, or pure magic.
When that does happen, you tend to forget the first half hour or so; that stretch where some apparently immature fly fisherman would be tempted to imitate his new daughter by stamping his wading boots and whining.
(Thank goodness that doesn’t apply to you or me.)
In this case, I sorta cracked it. Barely.
Well, not really.
I was able to get fish to eat, though before it all came together, I had one actually come up under my bug while aiming for the natural right behind it.
My simply too-big #18 parachute simply slid off his broad back, and I simply stood there wondering at the unfairness of it all.
The answer, of course, is that fairness isn’t a concept often adhered to in nature, and it wasn’t the trout’s fault I was stinking the place up.
The Ugly Reality
Chris Raine – who was ironically fishing my backup rod (an 8.5′ Raine prototype) because he’d grabbed the wrong rod tube on the way out of the shop – landed two nice fish.

Sure, his fish, but MY fly rod. I claim at least half of the trout's 15 inches
Naturally, I claimed ownership of half of both trout, suggesting it was a fool’s tax for grabbing the wrong rod (an obvious symptom of advancing age).
Just as naturally, he replied with a rude gesture.
I fished an 8.5′ Jim Reams hollowbuilt (a rod I love dearly for its smooth nature, but may sell because I’m not nearly caster enough to enjoy the taper when the bugs are on the water and I get impatient and start driving casts).
I had a total of four grabs, one brief hookup, one driven-by-frustration hookset (broke him off), and missed the other two on general principle.
In other words, I kinda sucked, and because I was preoccupied with rising fish, I can’t even save this fishing report with a handful of good pictures.
It was the kind of day that shows you brief flashes of promise, yet reminds you that you’re not nearly as good at this (or most other things) as your daydreams suggest you are.
Or more accurately, I’m not always as good at this as I was on the one day I did it all perfectly – a day which somehow becomes our benchmark for normalcy, which is self-deception raised to a high art.
While I’ll eventually adjust to the demands of the BWO hatch (I’m stocking up on #20 Roy Palm biot-bodied soft hackle emergers), I’ll also embrace the concept of letting the trout win the day without assuming I’ve lost my marbles.
See you on the river, Tom Chandler.




























Sometimes you eat the trout and sometimes the trout eats you.
Or something like that.
fishskicanoe(Quote)
One should never let reality influence your fishing memories, unless, of course, it’s one of those rare epic days.
Don(Quote)
Ditto FishSkiCanoe and Don.
“Bad Karma from prior lifetime”? HoooooWheeeee, so there’s somebody else with this problem? I guess it’s a relief to know that I’m not alone…
Still, even though we know what they are saying about us, or at least I do (“Didja see what that fool was slamming into the water? Check out that ridiculous hat.”); I take solace in the fact that they will never report what a fool I am to my friends and neighbors. Not a word…
Kentucky Jim(Quote)
Newman!
Turnip Truck Driver(Quote)
I sometimes claim 1/2 of the fish my buddy catches just because i drove his sorry butt to the water!
Guys Flies and Pies(Quote)
Great post. You speak for all fly anglers and our collective frustrations and successes. Well-written.
professor(Quote)
That we claim credit for our buddy’s fish is inevitable. The question revolves around how much of the fish we demand credit for.
It’s another of fly fishing’s philosophically significant questions.
Tom Chandler(Quote)
I’m sure there is a scientific equation that applies to claiming the fish our friends (and foes) take on a river. 1/2 of a fish for a borrowed fly rod. 1/4 of a fish for borrowed tippet. 1/8 of a fish for a pirated fly etc, etc… Of course, we can expand the theory to any person who catches a fish in the spot we were just standing — 1/3 claim on those fish based on pure prior occupancy principle alone and so on…..
Broken down through the complex levels of possible claims, a person could sit on a river bank and still claim a successful fishing trip~
Rebecca(Quote)
Hmmm…I believe Rebecca is onto something here.
Kentucky Jim(Quote)
Ok. Here is what really happened:
Tom and I had not actually fished together this season. So it was time.
Tom offered to drive. This was good. His gas.
We stopped at Amarattis, and each bought a breakfast burrito, and a drink. Came to 12 bucks. Tom bought. This was good. His money.
When we arrived at the selected site, fish were all ready working. This was good.
My rod was not in the rod tube. This was not good. Tom loaned me another rod. His rod. This was good.
Wading into the stream, Tom offered me the upstream spot, which he ALWAYS takes. This was unusual. But it was good.
The first fish I caught took me into the backing, and almost spooled me. This was unusual. When the fish was downstream some 50 yards, and in front of Tom, he reeled in and offered to net it. This was good. And he took a nice picture of its tail.
He then watched appreciatively as I hooked and landed (unaided) a slightly larger fish than the first.
BUT….while we fished for several hours, NOT ONCE did he offer me a sip of whiskey from his flask.
He is so selfish sometimes.
Chris Raine(Quote)
Liar.
I never watched “appreciatively.”
Instead, I was hoping you’d get hit by lightning. Sometimes, the truth doesn’t set you free…
Tom Chandler(Quote)
Love the “other side”.
Ice Fishing Man(Quote)