Following in the footsteps of earlier awards to writers John Gierach and Ted Williams, Fly Rod & Reel has chosen author Tom McGuane as their 2010 Angler of the Year.
With so many of McGuane’s novels and screenplays set against fly fishing locations – and populated by fly fishermen – it seems only right that McGuane would receive this honor on that basis alone.
To do so would be to overlook his publication of the best fly fishing essay book ever written: The Longest Silence.
That book – which solidified many of my observations about fly fishing – opens with a startling passage about fish counters robbing the trout (and the sport) of its soul:
The fisherman now is one who defies society, who rips lips, who drains the pool, who takes no prisoners, who is not to be confused with the sissy with the creel and bamboo rod. Granted, he releases what he catches, but in some cases, he strips the quarry of its perilous soul before tossing it back in the water. What was once a trout – cold, hard, spotted and beautiful – becomes “number seven.”
I could strip mine McGuane’s book for enough material to fill a hundred blog posts, but I’ll leave the discovery (or rediscovery) of those gems to my readers.
Instead, I’ll reprint part of what fly fishing publishing legend Nick Lyons has to say about McGuane on the FR&R site:
In Tom McGuane we have a different species of writer. He has loved fly-fishing for more than five decades, since he fished the rivers and small creeks of Michigan as a boy; he has pursued trout, false albacore, steelhead, bonefish, striped bass, permit and salmon with great passion and success; he has fished from Tierra del Fuego to Russia, Iceland, New Zealand, Ireland, Canada, Florida and throughout his now-native Montana, and widely elsewhere; and along with his great novels and stories and films has written, with dazzling skill, much about what he calls his “life in fishing.” He is Fly Rod & Reel’s Angler of the Year and my Angler for the Last Hundred Years.
McGuane says that “what fishing ought to be about” is to use “the ceremony of our sport and passion to arouse greater reverberations within ourselves.” Reverberations: a richer response to all aspects of the natural world, perhaps—and our responsibilities to it; something telling about ourselves, surely; more about our subtle connections to all the texture and detail of fly-fishing; and a lot about our understanding of leisure and friendship and expertness and the enduring value of ritual, and so much more. Mostly, what we know about these matters comes from those with words—words that shock us into some new awareness, that, long after we’ve read them, echo in our brains.
This is, of course, what we call “literature” which is not something fancy dan or pretentious or irrelevant to any other matter in the universe, not sentimental (which is exaggerating sniffles), not trading ever in clichés (which is like claiming fish you haven’t caught). McGuane does these things in a major body of nearly a dozen novels, from The Sporting Club in 1968 to one he just finished, in time for a trip this past summer to Iceland and his annual fall trip to the Dean for steelhead, around which week he says he designs his year, “for these pools, these beautiful fish.” And he does it in what has become a major body of work about fly fishing—parts of An Outside Chance, all of Live Water and The Longest Silence. He is, as all of the best writers must be, a man on whom nothing is lost.
He knows that “the best angling is always a respite from burden,” not part of a competition or PR jaunt or a chance to transact business with those you fish with or a banquet for your ego. He knows we need to be stewards and riverkeepers, lest “there will be less than nothing, remnant populations, put-and-take, dim bulbs following the tank truck.” He knows how to make memorable and precise observations about our emotions and affections: “Young anglers love new rivers the way they love the rest of their lives.”
Speaking as a writer, I revere McGuane for his ability to deftly peel back the unsightly layers that obscure what should be a beautiful sport. As a fly fisherman, I never tire of his obvious love for the sport itself.
See you with a good book, Tom Chandler.














{ 4 comments… read them below or add one }
Totally off topic but before I forget and assuming anyone cares, here goes.
Regarding the rubber sole vs felt wading boot issue:
My buddy forgot his boots for a Klamath steelhead session the other day. I loaned him my Simms G4 boots and used my old (beat to oblivion felt soled with a few studs left) Weinbrenners.
While my buddy looked like he was trying to fish in an ice rink, I felt at home in the old felt soled beaters. After comparing notes we agreed the felts were like rock climbing in precision shoes where a toe placement holds without fail and the rubber was like climbing the same face in lugged hiking boots. We did agree the Sims boot was more comfortable and walked better out of the water.
I do use studs so my experience is not not totally within Toms testing standards of studless.
Absent some yet to come compelling evidence the rubber prevents invasive introduction my next boots will be studded felt.
Andy andy marx(Quote)
Andy:
I’m two posts in the hole right now, but I tested the Simms Vibram soles (one with studs, one without) on Sunday, and the results weren’t all that edifying. I’ve got to get that one written, and I’ll copy and paste your comment over to it when I do. Tom Chandler(Quote)
Nick’s write-up certainly made me stop, think and be thankful for having known the simple pleasures that fly fishing offers. Not sure I can work that into the Thanksgiving dinner speech but I’ll try. Ken Sperry(Quote)
McGuane is one of the personalities in Tom Brokaw’s Boom! Voices of the Sixties. A really fun book to read, particularly for those who claim to not remember the era. And there are two shots of him — one contemp, looking elder Boomer, and another from the inhaling time, long-haired, denim shirt, member of the Eagles, c. 1970. DarrellKuni(Quote)