Montana Road Trip 2009: Fly Fishing Tiny Alpine Meadows for 100 Year-Old Mussels?

by Tom Chandler on July 20, 2009 · 13 comments

It’s tempting to say you leave a little piece of you behind every time you fish someplace beautiful, but only a mad poet would buy it – unless, of course, you actually did leave something behind.

Lately, we’ve conducted a small stream festival here on the Underground, and on the Montana Road Trip 2009, that wasn’t about to change.

If you're into beauty and wild trout, not a bad place to be...

The tiny meadow stream carefully not mentioned by name here was one we fly fished last year, and the fly fishing was the same small stream festival I remembered from 12 months ago.

The trout were still small – though we eked out a handful in the 11″-12″ range – and the fishing itself was something even a purist could love.

To the uninitiated, it would seem easy; the casts are short, the flies are floating, and the takes a little greedy.

Then again, the fish are spooky, the casting needs to be accurate to the inch, and the drifts surprisingly difficult.

Cutthroat trout go drab in the water, but neon in the sunlight.

And yes, there are more fly eating shrubs, trees and grasses than trout, so the price for a bad cast might be more than a few choice swear words.

Even when retrieving a snagged fly, you step carefully on this stream; it’s home to a rare freshwater mussel (the Western Pearlshell) that can live in excess of 100 years.

And yes, grinding a small colony of 70 year-old mussels into oblivion under your wading boot is not the memory you want to take from a day of fly fishing.

Western Pearlshell Mussels? These could have been here since WWI

It’s more than an “ooops” moment.

The (Uncelebrated) Grand Slam

Oddly – in the middle of cutthroat country – I found myself the owner of a Grand Slam: I caught a brown trout, a couple Brook trout, and many Westslope Cutthroats.

Brookie spots. Proof of a Grand slam - and too many non-natives?

In some instances, that’s cause for celebration – but only you’re not concerned about finding so many non-natives in a tiny alpine meadow creek. If [Name Redacted] and I go back, we’re packing a cooler and taking the Brookies and brown trout home for dinner.

Finding a brown trout this far up a cutthroat stream made our biologist friend sigh.

Catch and release has become something of a religion among fly fishermen, but sometimes the natives need a hand, and while the Brookie is still the Official Char of the Trout Underground, they simply don’t belong everywhere.

Plus they’re good to eat.

The Other Fishermen

Any time you stumble on a rarely fished stream, you assume complete and total ownership of it (at least in your head).

It may flow through public land and a (barely) drivable dirt road may cross it, but it’s yours, damnit.

So when you find a group of campers – including some who might even be fishermen – at the confluence of your tiny creek and the larger creek it feeds, you’re forgiven if your first thought is streak your face with mud, crawl down there through the brush, and go all Rambo on their camp.

It’s possible I accidentally vocalized some of that thinking, and [Name Redacted] gently reminded me I was standing on public land, and that the knee-high grasses on our tiny meadow stream looked undisturbed.

I mean, what fishermen wastes his time on a tiny meadow stream when a bigger version – with presumably bigger fish – runs right nearby?

Fair enough. Given all the trouble and worry that human greed has caused over the last 18 months, it’s refreshing to realize that wanton greed sometimes works in our favor.

Too small to be interesting? Nahhh...

Later – farther up the meadow – we’d stumble across a part of the meadow ripped up by ATV tracks (which also plowed through the stream at one point, which brought out that Rambo thing again), and sometimes you wonder why hopping on an otherwise useful ATV causes some people to immediately lose 30+ IQ points.

Enough said.

The Paragraph Where It Gets Mortal

Regular readers will recall my father’s death more than a year ago, despite the passage of time, a couple vials of his ashes sit perched on the shelf.

In truth, I didn’t know what to do with them.

My father was a big, gentle, quiet guy who took better care of us than he did himself – a guy who didn’t spend a lot of time “recreating” because that’s simply not what responsible, depression-era men did.

I’ve discovered you don’t get over a parent’s death as much as try to make peace with it, and while time and distance grant you a certain serenity, they don’t insulate you from the random thoughts that surprise you along the way.

Sometimes, I just like a picture - for no reason. Ok?

It’s too late to drag dad along on my adventures – some of which he would have enjoyed – but I am perfectly capable of depositing a few of his ashes in a tiny meadow stream, which links to a bigger freestone stream, which runs to a much bigger stream, which flows eventually to the Clarks Fork, which flows eventually to the Columbia River, which ultimately flows into the ocean.

That he might someday occupy the whole of the Columbia Basin watershed puts a smile on my face.

It also makes sense that a small part of my quiet, patient father now occupies a stream populated by freshwater mussels – which may have been quietly doing whatever mussels do since before he was born.

A thought like that grants an almost totemic power to things like small streams and ashes, and you ignore the wonderful symmetry of it at all your own peril.

If there’s a moral here, maybe it’s this: maybe the mad poets among us know something we don’t.

A tiny, grassy, Montana meadow stream - a good place to hang out for a while.

More Montana

The Underground’s Montana Road Trip 2009 took a turn for the stormy after [Name Redacted] and I returned from our small stream odyssey, but that’s fodder for my next post.

See you on the river, Tom Chandler.

Inner Landscape, Montana Meadow Stream

Sometimes you love an image, but don't know where to put it. This belongs here.

Technorati Tags: , , ,

{ 1 trackback }

The Underground’s 2009 Year in Review (in Words & Pictures) | The Trout Underground Fly Fishing Blog
January 4, 2010 at 9:28 pm

{ 12 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Gareth July 20, 2009 at 9:18 am

Fantastic. It’s as simple as that.  

(Quote)

Reply

2 Bob Laskodi July 20, 2009 at 9:19 am

Tom, it’s perfectly acceptable to take a few of your dad’s ashes and sprinkle them in the stream while you’re fishing. That way he can still be fishing with you in spirit. I’m doing the same thing with my son when I go to the perfect endless hatch in the sky.  

(Quote)

Reply

3 Turnip Truck Driver July 20, 2009 at 10:16 am

TC,

Thank you for this…………….

“I’ve discovered you don’t get over a parent’s death as much as try to make peace with it, and while time and distance grant you a certain serenity, they don’t insulate you from the random thoughts that surprise you along the way.”  

(Quote)

Reply

4 Cutthroat Stalker (Scott C) July 20, 2009 at 1:58 pm

Excellent writing Tom!

The cutts and waters they come from–you just can’t beat it. I’m glad to see others enjoying, and writing about, these little waters and little fish with big color. It is easy to start thinking of such places as “yours” when so few others take the time. Becoming protective is understandable.

-scott c  

(Quote)

Reply

5 Flykuni July 20, 2009 at 3:39 pm

Many thanks.  

(Quote)

Reply

6 Smarter and Better Looking Brother July 20, 2009 at 8:51 pm

“That he might someday occupy the whole of the Columbia Basin watershed is a thought that puts a smile on my face.”

Nicely done Tom. Dad never did travel much, but I know he would have really liked what you have in mind.  

(Quote)

Reply

7 paul w July 20, 2009 at 11:05 pm

“I’ve discovered you don’t get over a parent’s death as much as try to make peace with it, and while time and distance grant you a certain serenity, they don’t insulate you from the random thoughts that surprise you along the way.”

Yes, very nicely done, Tom. My dad died in late 2007, and I can certainly relate to that truism.
I’m currently helping my brother sort of stuff from our parents house, and it was so difficult to throw stuff out (we’re donating what we can).
It becomes easier, of course, but it’s always touched with sadness.
As for his ashes, we’re spreading his on a beach in the Great Barrier Reef (Australia), at the exact spot he spread mum’s ashes all those years ago.
Such is life, eh?  

(Quote)

Reply

8 Eric July 21, 2009 at 5:27 am

Great post, TC. Especially the paragraph about your dad. I lost my mom 4 years ago and spent this year on the anniversary on a small stream, more wooded, but similar to the one in this post. Excellent tribute to send your dads ashes into the current. Can’t think of a better place to be.

I’ve grappled with what to do when I catch a non native fish in “my” small stream. It hasn’t ever been officially stocked, and the stretch I fish is fed by 20ft waterfalls and ends at a 60+ft waterfall, so I’m pretty sure they didn’t run up or spill out of the other non stocked ponds, but regardless they’re there. They are naturally reproducing, but it threatens our native brookies. Rainbows, despite being wild, are becoming ever more prevalent in the stream. I am on the fence about whether to remove them or to let them be for the worm anglers and campers to catch and eat. They’re bigger than the brookies in the stream (by an order of magnitude, check my blog to see the photos) so clearly pose a predation threat.  

(Quote)

Reply

9 Harry July 21, 2009 at 5:27 am

One of your best Tom.  

(Quote)

Reply

10 chuck horton July 22, 2009 at 10:28 am

If I could find this beautiful stream I would be the happiest person in the world. Beautiful and so well written. I have reread this and enjoy it more everytime, thank you, Chuck Horton  

(Quote)

Reply

11 Pastor Ben July 22, 2009 at 2:38 pm

hey there

I was glad to read that you and “he who shall not be named” had a good time…I had a nice vist with [name redacted] while I was stayin’ in his home town early this spring…My father passed in 1971, and he is still present in my thoughts, and prayers…I think your on the right track with your statement..”get over a parent’s death as much as try to make peace with it”.. maybe we just learn to live with that hole in our heart/lives…Great post next time you talk to [name redacted] tell him ‘yo’ for me…and that we had a great Mothers day hatach in my valley this year…

Grace and peace
Ben  

(Quote)

Reply

12 Michael Lanning July 23, 2009 at 10:08 am

Love this artical. Would sure like to have some of these small streams in my area. Great thanks.  

(Quote)

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: