Fly Fishing,    fishing,    Fishing Report,    patagonia,    rogue river,    Simms,    steelhead,    upper rogue,    wading boots

Fly Fishing the Rogue River When Fly Fishing May Not Be the Point

By Tom Chandler 4/7/2009

At the end of a long winter (even an easy long winter), 80 degree feels about ten degrees hotter than the world's ever been, and you marvel at the feel of sunlight glowing directly on skin sans a fleece buffer between the two.

Though I had to cut and run from work on Monday to fish the Rogue with Dave Roberts, I rationalized the escape thusly: I wanted to.

Dave Roberts bravely testing wading boots for the Undergrounders.

It's not the kind of thing that makes clients happy, but as everyone knows (at least after reading this), an under-recreated writer is a boring writer, and at some point, you've gotta fly fish.

For those looking for big fish stories, I'll be blunt: stop reading here.

Though Dave Roberts knows the Upper Rogue like the rest of us know our living rooms, this was not a hard-charging, balls-to-the-wall, extreme fishing adventure.

Instead, we more or less doodled along the river, fishing for steelhead (one of which bit a streamer, but came unbuttoned after a couple seconds). We also landed a pair of 11" trout who apparently didn't know w you're not allowed to fish for trout on the Rogue right now, which suggests the trout have yet to invent their own version of Twitter.

Looks pretty and scenic from the shore - until you realize your ride to the ramp is leaving.

The Testing Continues
We did manage to further the world's scientifically derived knowledge about a pair of the next-generation rubber-soled wading boots, testing the newly arrived Simms wading boots against the previously reviewed Patagonias.

The Rogue is positively filled with green snot-covered rocks the size of your average loaf of bread, making it an ideal testing ground for rubber soled-boots.

Slimy enough? Our testing grounds...

On two separate runs, Roberts and I got out and tromped around, then swapped boots and did it again. (The rocks were slimy enough that a fair amount of detached green stuff floated downstream when we waded.)

While more testing is needed (preferably on some remote BC steelhead river, though budgetary concerns suggest the Upper Sac will have to do), we both came to the rather surprising conclusion that these things worked pretty damned well in a situation where we didn't expect they would.

The work is hard, but no sacrifice is too great for my readers.

It's possible the Simms' more aggressive tread pattern gave it a slight edge in the "greasy bowling ball" portion of the test, though we've yet to test the Simms boots in varied Upper Sacramento or small stream conditions (coming soon).

At this point, I'd have no qualms about using either boot on the Rogue. And Roberts - who admitted to reading my reports on Patagonia's boots with some skepticism - was ready to buy either pair, though the Simms fit him best (the Patagonias felt more comfy to me, telling us what we already know - different shoes fit different feet... differently).

More Testing
Plenty more to come from the Underground; I also concluded testing on the Redington 6wt rod && reel combo, and I've added it to the "write this" pile (which has grown pretty sizable).

Several DVDs are waiting for reviews, and yes, there's always the chance for another fishing report.

Hookset, in progress.

See you slaving away, Tom Chandler.

Get the Newsletter


AuthorPicture

Tom Chandler

As the author of the decade leading fly fishing blog Trout Underground, Tom believes that fishing is not about measuring the experience but instead of about having fun. As a staunch environmentalist, he brings to the Yobi Community thought leadership on environmental and access issues facing us today.

[...] Simms vibram sole feels hard and stiff, yet gripped beautifully on the Rogue River’s rock-snot, cobble-sized testing grounds (the aggressive tread pattern might have something to do wtih [...]
0
0
Thanks for the feedback. I know the Patagonias - with their softer rubber sole - grip like crazy glue on dry rocks, and I'm looking forward to testing the Simms in those environments.
0
0
TC & Georgie...the hike in to pit 3 on the Pit river and the ROUND rolling rocks in the area wet or dry ....new Simms (hard rubber), damn near broke my neck all day. No grip at all.
0
0
@Sully: I think they're the same uppers with the new sole (most of the boots still available in felt). That said, I haven't yet tested them in a small stream environment yet, so I wouldn't pull the trigger yet. @Georgie: They worked well on the river, but I haven't yet tested them in other environments. The rubber feels much harder than the Patagonia stuff, and I did catch myself wondering if the ... more grip we enjoyed on the greasy stuff wasn't due to the aggressive tread pattern. More testing to come.
0
0
The new Simms have a much harder sole. I recently borrowed my brother's pair for a day trip on a mountain stream (climbing big smooth - in most cases dry - rocks). I barely survived. I would have been better off wearing rollerskates.
0
0
A question for Dave. Have you worn Simms boots before? I wear their aqua-stealth boots right now and they fit great. If their soft rubber versions are based on the same boot they've made a sale.
0
0
Any time TC comes up to fish is just plain fun for me. It's what a true fishing partner is about. Spotting a pair of Ospreys in a tree, playing with Boo (my lab) in the back of the boat. Just sitting back and watching TC cast, (he is a very smooth caster). Having lunch on the side of the river and have a soon to be mommy goose come off her nest and scare the crap out of us. Any fish we got was a big ... more bonus for me, jut being on the river with a really good friend was all that is meant to be. David PS had more whining from the Lab than TC for a change wasn't bad ether.
0
0
Great Hookset picture! I feel like it's a good thing Trout haven't figured out twitter yet, They seem to play mind games with me enough here in Maine. God only knows how interesting my fishing would get if they formed a coalition against me. -Ben
0
0

Discover Your Own Fishing and Hunting Adventures

With top destinations, guided trips, outfitters and guides, and river reports, you have everything you need.