Fly Fishing,    Flies,    Fly Tying,    nymphs,    soft hackle,    stimulators

Simple Flies: A Fly Tying Primer for the Lazy & Weak

By Tom Chandler 3/10/2009

It's the time of year when those too lazy to shovel snow who live in warmer climates start chirping about spring, yet in the mountains, March is more promise than actual delivery.

The Upper Sacramento is typically running high (with temps in the mid-50s forecast this week, it's going to run even higher), real spring weather can be more than a month away, and you can still deceive yourself into thinking you've got time to tie that hundred dozen flies you planned for the winter.

OK, I'll be up front: I'm not going to make it to one hundred dozen. In fact, because I'm writing this instead of tying those, I'll be lucky to make it to a couple dozen, which makes the following fact a good thing: I like simple flies.

Really simple flies.

The Annual Fly Freak Out
Not only am I forced to confront my essential laziness, it's about this time of year that my love for simple flies is taken to absurd new heights; every late winter, I find myself idly toying with the idea of stripping my fly selection down to a mindlessly bare essential - like fishing a whole year with flies tied from nothing but grizzly hackle and Hare's Ear dubbing.

That's something I probably couldn't get away with, but I bet I could get away tying and fishing nothing but soft hackles.

One fly, all year? Could a lazy/greedy fly fisherman survive one year on soft hackles?

You can effectively fish soft hackles as everything from tiny midge nymphs to mayfly emergers to caddis to small streamers, though most people don't - a reality which suggests soft hackles need a better publicist.

It's an interesting idea (and the materials would be wildly affordable), but it's just something I threaten to do in front of my friends ("Just put the hackle pliers down and back away" Dave Roberts will say, "and nobody gets hurt.").

I haven't yet pulled the trigger, and probably never will.

After all, I'm lazy but I'm also greedy, and while I've successfully whittled my fly selection down to a handful of simple flies, I haven't yet worked myself up to what would amount to a fly fishing stunt (though it would make interesting blog fodder).

Still how little could I sneak by with that wouldn't amount to a stunt? Let's see:

  • Parachute dries (size && color to match the handful of mayfly hatches in this part of the world)

  • Stimulators (from small caddis sizes to the big, deadly dark numbers)

  • A small handful of soft hackle patterns (PTs to Hare's Ears to biot bodies, they're the force multiplier of the fly world)

  • Woolly Buggers


Sure, there are big gaping holes in that list, but you'd be surprised what you could accomplish by stretching the definition of "soft hackle" even a little.

In fact, soft hackles could cover everything from midge pupae to stonefly nymphs with a detour into emerging caddis, PT nymphs, and emerging, in-the-film mayflies.

I think I could pull it off.

The flies in the minimalist ointment here are the patterns sent to me by well-meaning friends, apparently unaware I'm trying to kick a bad habit.

Dave Roberts keeps waving innovative March Brown patterns under my nose, and [name redacted] keeps contributing BWO patterns that seemingly never fail (the Roy Palm  soft hackle emerger rarely fails either, but it's hard to see).

Then there's my growing interest in streamers, and while I could get by with Woolly Buggers in two colors (black && silver/white), a plain brown package just arrived from Ian Rutter's end of the country stuffed with what may be the perfect streamer, though more (and serious) testing on smallies, rainbows and big brown trouts is desperately needed (yes, I know where a few lurk).

In short, I may be simultaneously lazy and greedy, but when it comes to slimming down my fly selection, I'm also apparently weak (Hi, I'm Tom, and I'm powerless in the face of free flies).

See you at the vise (barely), Tom Chandler

, , , ,


AuthorPicture

Tom Chandler

As the author of the decade leading fly fishing blog Trout Underground, Tom believes that fishing is not about measuring the experience but instead of about having fun. As a staunch environmentalist, he brings to the Yobi Community thought leadership on environmental and access issues facing us today.

15 comments
Excellent...
0
0
Its true TC, the Marines are a department of the Navy. The Men's department
0
0
@Benjami: I admit that in the past, I had some hesitancy about fishing with a guy who could kill me in .8 seconds using only a paper clip, but once I started stuffing my fly box, I got over it.@Sam: Someone once told me Marines were simply sailors the Navy couldn't teach to swim.
0
0
This thread has gone in so many different confusing directs. I just now stopped laughing after 10 minutes and came back to a calm state where I could reply. Scam a marine? Priceless. Which I could make the drive down to Albany for the show. Bummer
0
0
Beaver.... but do you really want to scam an old Marine rowing your ass down the river? Scam a Marine...you bet, in a heart beat. I had to carry them Navy rejects for two years. Dave Carpenter, I'll look you up. Look forward to meeting you. I will say a prayer for you...your life is about to change...you be the Judge weather it's for the good.
0
0
Soft hackles and midge larvaes are about the only flies I'm capable of tying. As for parachutes - those are about the only dries smaller than 14 that I can see on the water. Lazy and weak? But if I weren't, I'd probably be defining myself by my career...
0
0
David Roberts: For a few of the moochers, from now on it would be very wise to always wade in front of the boat. That way if I remember to get even (the big word is remember anymore ) I can't leave you on the island at pump hole. Umpqua Beaver, you are a alright (even if you where Air Force.' He always comes with great Scotch. Hope to see some of you trout undergrounders at the Albany show this weekend. ... more Stop by and see and say hi.TC the March Browns are still coming off.David David, If the schedule is correct it looks like you're tying on Saturday Morning. I'll look you up. Look forward to meeting you. Dave
0
0
Parachutes and Stimi's don't fall under my definition of "simple". I'd whittle it down to Soft Hackles, Copper Johns, and simpler Stimi with a hot butt and single continuous hackle butt to eye. Tom for your simple and streamer foci, try a marvelously simple one called the marabou minnow: marabou tail, chenille body and wrapped around beadchain eyes. Size 10 3xl is a winner, paler bugger colors perform ... more best. A soft hackle right behind the eyes couldn't hurt.
0
0
For a few of the moochers, from now on it would be very wise to always wade in front of the boat. That way if I remember to get even (the big word is remember anymore ) I can't leave you on the island at pump hole. Umpqua Beaver, you are a alright (even if you where Air Force.' He always comes with great Scotch. Hope to see some of you trout undergrounders at the Albany show this weekend. Stop by ... more and see and say hi. TC the March Browns are still coming off. David
0
0
The soft hackle is a great fly. I once had the opportunity to sit in on a lecture given by Rachel Andras. The subject of flies came up, and I can remember her saying that the best fly in your fly box is the one you have confidence in, along with plenty of split shot. Everyone in the audience laughed, but I've found that to be true more often that not, especially on the Upper Sac during the summer ... more months.
0
0
Not that I haven't scored a fly or two myself, but do you really want to scam an old Marine rowing your ass down the river? Enlightenment could come in a "riffle".
0
0
Tom Chandler: As for what we'll call “The Dave Roberts Fly Tying Stimulus Package,” how do you think I've avoided tying a single stonefly dry for the last five years? I know your type, lazy SOB's. But in all seriousness, does that really work for you guys? Everyone here protects their flies like gold and keeps their boxes padlocked. P.S. Tom, your article inspired me so much I had to make note ... more of it on my blog. You read my mind.
0
0
These days, I'm never sure if the Trout Underground is serving as some kind of online confessional or simply home to a den of thieves. As for what we'll call "The Dave Roberts Fly Tying Stimulus Package," how do you think I've avoided tying a single stonefly dry for the last five years?
0
0
Talking about a fly "diet" is admirable. Boiling your selection down to the basic essentials is the New Frugality, and a worthy undertaking. Bumming flies off your friends incessantly to make up for what you're not carrying, well - that's just priceless.
0
0
Let's see, five trips with Dave (the big bearded one), so far this year and very trip he supplies the flies.Soon as he turns his back I pop off the fly and put it in my vest or shirt pocket and say "Hey what kind of a knot you tyng ...flies gone", so he ties on another and during the day I do this, oh maybe ten times, ( with one actual bush hangup and now I've got a fair supply of really good flies ... more and he is none the wiser. If you don't tell him my secret I'll share it with you and by this time next year, you will have not tied one fly, but fished some really top quality flies all year. How simple ( or lazy ) is that? not signed to protect the innocent
0
0

Discover Your Own Fishing and Hunting Adventures

With top destinations, guided trips, outfitters and guides, and river reports, you have everything you need.