Writer Thomas McGuane’s work simply gives me the chills; he places words end-to-end with the precision of a master machinist – but one graced with a poet’s perception.
In a rare newspaper article (is the Wall Street Journal now courting the outdoor crowd?), he talks bird hunting and bird dogs – poleaxing the gun craziness, anti-hunting effluent, and political posturing that burdens so many conversations about the sport.
As is typical, McGuane reels off one head-nodding passage after another, and fair use only allows me to whet your appetites with a couple short passages, incenting (nay, forcing) you to read the whole thing from start to finish on the WSJ site.
McGuane’s lead accurately describes a scene every dog owner knows by heart:
On a bright and cold October morning in Montana, my dogs Abby and Daisy, The Pointer Sisters, are in my closet helping me select my clothes. On the left end of the rack are everyday clothes; on the far right are coats and ties for the occasional urban jaunt; and in the middle, clothes for sport, especially hunting. Here sit the two girls, tails whisking the floor between the shoes. They moan, grumble and pant wishfully while my hand hovers over the coat hangers. I shouldn’t do this as dogs don’t enjoy being trifled with.
They know where the thorn-proof pants hang, since the red suspenders dangle to eye level for them, but they watch my hand. I don’t move; Abby turns to stare at my boots with such longing she must think they can scoop me up and take me into the hills. Finally, Daisy can’t stand it and barks at me: I pull the hunting pants from their hanger and with a cry of triumph they scramble out of the closet to watch me dress.
After beautifully describing the hunting experience (which is not too far removed from the fishing experience), McGuane eviscerates a couple sacred cows:
There is so much in the air suggesting that hunting is an anachronism that it’s easy for a hunter to feel he is an anachronism too. An old fishing friend of mine said, as we headed home from an agreeable outing, “I thank God I’m not a day under 80.” I’m a meat eater and have the teeth to prove it, but greatly pity the creatures in the domestic meat businesses. An industrial chicken factory gives me heartburn and Thanksgiving is a tragedy for turkeys. I don’t wear camo, don’t belong to the NRA and haven’t been to a gun show since the jovial grandmother sitting behind the pile of machine guns said to me, “Goblins get in your house you’ll love having one of these.”
Then he once again perfectly sums up the dog experience:
The dogs are everything, and they want to hunt, too. Bird dogs plead with you to imagine the great things you could be doing together. Their delight is a lesson in the bliss of living. As Bob Dylan says, “You’ve got to serve somebody.” I serve my dogs and in return, they glom the sofa.
Go. Read. Enjoy.





























Thomas McGuane is a Master.
Anyone not familiar with his writing and history in the sport of fly fishing should read, The Longest Silence… it’s gotta be one of the best compilations of fishing essays ever written. You will read it again and again every few years.
Dave Neal(Quote)
Thanks for the link Tom. Can’t ever get enough of McGuane. The skwala hatch shut down with the snow here today, but the gray drakes were pretty decent for some flat water dry fly action yesterday.
Taku(Quote)
Terrific essay. My shotgun-toting friends especially enjoyed it. Made me wish I’d put my lab through some formal birding training, despite the fact that I don’t hunt. Some of the things she does by instinct alone are pretty amazing.
Thanks for sharing, TC.
MHH(Quote)
Marred by the homage paid to SWPL (regardless of race) orthodoxy by the gratuitous dismissal of the NRA and gun shows. I didn’t vote in the last election for POTUS ( I thought it was a beauty contest in the most literal sense of the term), but I almost wish McCain had won in order to give these little bigots a touch of heartburn.
Possession of automatic weapons is highly regulated:
http://www.guncite.com/gun_control_gcfullau.html
(…)
t has been unlawful since 1934 (The National Firearms Act) for civilians to own machine guns without special permission from the U.S. Treasury Department. Machine guns are subject to a $200 tax every time their ownership changes from one federally registered owner to another, and each new weapon is subject to a manufacturing tax when it is made, and it must be registered with the Bureau of Alcohol Tobacco and Firearms (BATF) in its National Firearms Registry.
To become a registered owner, a complete FBI background investigation is conducted, checking for any criminal history or tendencies toward violence, and an application must be submitted to the BATF including two sets of fingerprints, a recent photo, a sworn affidavit that transfer of the NFA firearm is of “reasonable necessity,” and that sale to and possession of the weapon by the applicant “would be consistent with public safety.” The application form also requires the signature of a chief law enforcement officer with jurisdiction in the applicant’s residence.
(…)
icr(Quote)
I don’t even know what SWPL means, and I have a feeling I’m one of the “little bigots” you’re wishing acid reflux on, but speaking as a shooter and gun owner, let me guarantee you this: this is NOT going to become a gun control thread, especially since everybody knows exactly what McGuane was talking about.
Fini.
Tom Chandler(Quote)
Stuff White People Like?
http://stuffwhitepeoplelike.com/2008/02/04/53-dogs/
MHH(Quote)
I knew fly fishing was the wrong place to build a blog. Social commentary (including celebrity spotting and photos) is clearly better. Damn.
Tom Chandler(Quote)
That is a GREAT essay. However I’m detecting a note of nihilism in this essay and in some of the recent work by Gierach as well. As a member of the younger end of the demographic spectrum I must say that I try to hold a more positive outlook, if for nothing more than the mere hope that I live to see the future that so many have such little hope for. Its fun to imagine yourself as an anachronism but hunting is and shall be big business, for better or worse.
Oh and don’t worry Mr Chandler, SWPL was sooo, last year.
Ethan(Quote)
TC: Being the all powerful blogmeister, you can squash whatever comments you don’t like – how does being omnipotent (at least here) feel?
And Ethan’s comment does have a good ring to it – it is human nature to think the good old days were better, when some things were, but others were not. While I might lament the number of people on the rivers today, it can serve to protect them too. And the fishing is actually better on some western MT streams than in the 80′s.
Plus I like what This is Fly (and Singlebarbed brownlining) is doing for fly fishing and fishing in general – pushing the boundaries of what might be considered “acceptable”. Singlebarbed certainly brings back some of my carp, catfish and bass fishing beginnings.
Glad to hear SWPL is last year, guess I must have been busy hunting and fishing and missed it.
Taku(Quote)
TC,
Thanks for the link. The first passage from the article is spot on, a scenario and dog owner can relate too. The entire article is golden!
Benjamin Rioux(Quote)
@Ethan: Great comment, and probably fodder for a whole post (you wanna write it?). When I spoke to Gierach I suggested seeing hints of impending mortality when I first read his “Grave of the Unknown Fisherman.” He pointed out that during that stretch, he’d been in the hospital for some time with a fairly serious health issue.
That a writer’s state of mind – and current circumstances – would appear in his prose is a given. What I can’t quite buy into is the idea that it qualifies as nihilism, though I think it’d be interesting as hell to have that discussion (I know, it amuses me too).
McGuane’s always been a sharp-eyed observer, and in fact, his passage about trout being robbed of their beauty by fishermen intent on a body count is in the same vein – and it’s not really new. After all, suggesting some things are going to hell in a handbasket isn’t the same as suggesting they used to be less so.
@Taku: The ability to squash out-of-control comments is one reason why blogs rarely become what I’ve called the “race to the bottom” experienced by so many other online media.
Tom Chandler(Quote)
Tom,
Thanks so much for dropping in the Tom McGuane article. Having only recently left the corporate (go-go-go) world and (mostly) retired to our little cabin in upstate NY, it is doubtful that I would ever have seen the WSJ article. Great publication for those who worry about jobs, bank accounts, business planners, and black berries (not the real fruit), and all things big business; just not for me. Anyhow, when we moved back here from S. Oregon, I brought along a little, brand new (to me) Gordon Setter rescue dog named Daisy. We have ruffed grouse here and it is one of my great pleasures in life to walk out the back door and watch the little dog try to puzzle out those brown bombshells in the old apple orchard and briers. She still has alot to learn and I continue to learn each day. Again, thank you for including Tom McGuane’s article. He is the best we have today and it’s a credit to your blog that you have no qualms whatsoever taking a brief excursion away from flyfishing to other (equally weighty and serious, of course) topics.
Dan Hayes
Dan Hayes(Quote)
I like McGuane’s writing. The best essay he did, The Heart of the Game, ran in the first issue of Outside, before it became a glitzy, outdoor version of al those other X Gen ‘men’s mags”.
Re: Ethan’s comment, you had to have been there to know. Before graphite, before fishermen spoke Latin, before catch and release, and before The Movie.
I do bird dogs. And I fish. That is almost enough to fill up a life.
Mike Spies(Quote)