Development, drought and dewatering in the Northern Rockies are changing the streams and rivers of Montana — and not in a way that’s going to make too many fly fishermen happy: (found via Ted William’s Excellent Blog)
But now, a series of recent studies show the future of Montana’s fabled waters is in doubt. These days, drinking out of the once-pristine Gallatin is not recommended. There’s more algae on the river’s bed, and soon, thanks to increased sedimentation, those mayflies may disappear entirely. Assailed by drought, development, pollution and dewatering, the Blue Ribbon trout streams that form the great Missouri River are troubled waters, indeed.
An article in the Montana Standard suggests the biomass in many rivers and tribs in the Upper Missouri River basin is shifting from coldwater species to those that thrive in warmer waters:
At the Bozeman meeting of the American Fisheries Society last year, Dan McGuire, a researcher who has been studying the Upper Missouri basin for 30 years, broke grim news with his presentation, titled: “Long-term macroinvertebrate monitoring indicates fundamental environmental changes in the Upper Missouri River basin.â€
McGuire looked at historic levels of aquatic insects, plants, sedimentation and flow rates on the Madison, Jefferson, Big Hole and Upper Missouri Rivers. After repeating a 1978 Fish, Wildlife and Parks study on the Jefferson River, McGuire wrote: “The differences in the macroinvertebrate community were dramatic.†Like the Gallatin EIS, McGuire found the traditional clean and cold water species of insects were diminishing and being replaced by non-insects such as “mollusks, worms, crustaceans.â€
While McGuire says the main cause of the changes appears to be drought, he also mentions water use and management.
And Enjoy That Prozac — Compliments of Your Neighbor
Warming, over-fertilized rivers draw a knowing (if grim) nod from most of us, but later in the article we stumbled across some even less pleasing information — the damage done to groundwater supplies by the thousands of new septic tanks added to the landscape due to Montana’s development boom.
What are we talking about? Get this — the drugs that have already passed through someone’s body and septic tank (wretch):
What was perhaps less expected, but much more shocking to the general public, was the discovery of 22 PPCPs (pharmaceuticals, personal care products, endocrine disrupting compounds and pesticides). Of the 38 public and private domestic water wells tested, a shocking 80 percent contained the antibiotic sulfamethoxazole (SMX) and 40 percent contained the broadleaf weed-control herbicide atrazine, with lower detection rates for carbamazepine (an anticonvulsant, anti-manic agent used to treat epilepsy, neuralgia and bipolar disorders), dilantin (an anti-seizure medication) and diclofenac (a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug that works by reducing hormones that cause inflammation and pain in the body).
Also present were detectable amounts of DEET (insect repellant); Ibuprofen (anti-inflammatory); 17-betaestradiol (estrogen); Bisphenol A (used in plastics, but also activates estrogen receptors); Diethylstilbestrol (estrogen replacement removed from market in 1997); estriol (estrogen); fluoxetine (anti-depressant); gemfibrozil (cholesterol treatment); meprobamate (used to treat anxiety/tension); naproxen (antiinflammatory); oxybenzone (sunscreen); pentoxifylline (treatment of leg pain from poor blood flow); progesterone (female hormone replacement); triclosan (antibacterial agent in soaps and detergents); and timethoprim (used to treat urinary tract infections).
Sure, the glass half full guy realizes he’s enjoying a free dose of Prozac just by drinking from his well, but if you’re not necessarily disposed towards drinking someone else’s chemicals, you might just shudder a bit.
Concentrations of most of the drugs are low, but then, they’re talking about the groundwater that folks drink every day. Exactly what would be the effect of a lifetime of that kind of exposure?
No, we don’t know either.
See you at the water faucet, Tom Chandler.




























Yep, have heard these reports. Considering the mix of chemicals, it is a shame that Hunter S. Thompson is no longer with us. All we have to do now is carry a Sierra cup with us, take a dip of the Gallatin’s finest and spend the rest of the day on the Gonzo fishing trip. Makes the heavy metals on the Clark Fork seem pretty tame. What I wonder is why are all those things showing up in the Bozone area that is supposed to be the conservative stronghold. Makes me wonder what the Missoula aquifer is like….
Big Sky Taku(Quote)
Nummy! All those dudes with the big bucks building houses along the river must need stiffer rods.
Water is going to hell all over the west, Montana is another casualty, or on its way. Should we be thinking Bass Pro tournaments?
I am guessing that the Bitteroot is in about the same shape if not worse. You could fish at the junction of the Clark Fork and the Bitteroot, get your Prozac and Ibuprofen from one and Arsenic and heavy metals from the other and by mid summer take a warm bath in either.
fishhead(Quote)
Taku: You’d have to assume Missoula’s water carries more hallucinagenics, but of course, they’d be organic…
Fish: We’re not writing any epitaphs yet, and you’ve gotta figure testing of wells in other areas would turn up similar findings, but it does kinda put a damper on the whole “pristine wilderness” thing.
Frankly, I’m inclined to follow Sully’s route on this one – make sure word gets out about the hallucinogenic water, the deadly grizzly bears, the muffy-eating wolves and the roving bands of armed, pissed militia, and see if the gears of development don’t grind to a halt.
Kinda makes me wish we had wolves and grizzlies in Siskiyou County…
Tom Chandler(Quote)
You should have seen the Mo this summer: strange, ribbon-like algae and lots of it; all sorts of new construction along the river banks (doesn’t everyone want their very own fishing lodge?); and horrible mid-summer fishing. Oh yeah, living the dream.
Stacie(Quote)
At least we Montana-loving fisherfolk still have the clean and cold South Fork of the Flathead. While a pain to get to, it’s nice to know that that river and it’s entire watershed is forever protected in the Bob Marshall Wilderness Area. And what wild and strong cutthroats it has!
Josh(Quote)
All this is making Union Pacific’s riverfront ownership sound pretty good…
Smellslikefish(Quote)
They’ve already dumped a tanker of herbicide in the river; one wonders what a boxcar full of viagra tablets would do to the trout population…
Tom Chandler(Quote)