Fall Fly Fishing’s Top 5 Flies (in Maine). And A Fabulous Underground Contest

by Tom Chandler on September 24, 2007

Fly fishing in Maine is pretty damned different from fly fishing here in the mountains of Northern California, but a “Top 5 Flies for Fall” article from Maine fascinates me anyway.

Sure, in this list from the Kennebec Journal, two of the top five flies are streamers (not very common out here, but maybe they should be). Still it’s fun reading. My favorite of the five flies? The Montreal Whore:

MONTREAL WHORE: Like the Wood Special, this is another bright attractor streamer fly that garners plenty of attention for its, um, color…. Holt continues and offers up the Montreal Whore. “When the local pastor comes in, he always asks for the Montreal ‘Concubine,’ ” Holt says, smiling. “But, like the name says, it’s flashy and full of action.

The Contest: Win Fabulous Prizes

My Top 5 Flies for Fall on the Upper Sacramento would be a less thrilling read: October Caddis dry and nymph, BWO parachute, BWO emerger, and… well, something else. Effective for sure, but they lack the ring of “Montreal Whore” or the “Peacock Bugmeister.”

That’s why I’ve decided to give the Dying October Caddis pattern I tie — the one I mentioned in a previous article (elk hair underbody)a catchy, attention-grabbing name. That’s where you come in.

octobercaddispattern
A survivor from last year. Elk underbody, hackle collar, splayed wing.

You come up with a catchy, can’t-be-forgotten name, place it in the comments section, and the winning writer (judged by the L&T Nancy and myself) receives my review copy of Mark D. Williams’ “So Many Fish, So Little Time” — a book whose writing I liked a lot, though I felt it tried to cover too much ground.


Win this Fabulous Prize.

I know exactly what you’re thinking: “Won’t I have to report a prize this valuable on my tax return?” Our answer? It’s not our problem (Expert Legal Opinion: it’s a long book, and should last through most of your prison sentence).

Contest rules? Immediate disqualification for Shasta Whore, or almost any variation thereof (this won’t stop a few of the regulars, but it had to be said).

Fire away, you literate bastards. See you at the judge’s table, Tom Chandler.

UPDATE: When I tie more of whatever this ends up being called, I’m using some of this stuff.

ANOTHER UPDATE: Singlebarbed tied a variant of the thing using his sparkly, Holloywood-style dubbing:

The Singlebarbed Caddis

[tags]fly fishing, flies, maine, october caddis[/tags]

{ 66 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Brian Sims 09.24.07 at 9:58 am

How about Orange Blossom Special

Quote

2 Steve 09.24.07 at 10:04 am

Death on a Shingle

Quote

3 Steve 09.24.07 at 10:07 am

PS I’m not paying shipping.

Quote

4 Steve 09.24.07 at 10:09 am

Last Entry: The Dingle Berry

Still not paying shipping.

Sincerely,

Steve (The Literate Bastard)

Quote

5 Will 09.24.07 at 10:09 am

The “First Freeze Flailer”

Quote

6 Tom Chandler 09.24.07 at 10:37 am

Steve: No shipping, but there is the $17.95 handling fee…

Quote

7 Steve Altshuler 09.24.07 at 10:50 am

Candy’s Caddis
or
Orangatan
or
Fall’s Maiden
or
Fall’s Maple Maiden

Regards from Albany,NY,
Steve Altshuler

Quote

8 Loon 09.24.07 at 10:52 am

Firehaus Sexxx

October porn

Orange butt floss

ps: you site visits just went through the roof! ;-)

Quote

9 Ethan 09.24.07 at 10:55 am

Attention Whore

Quote

10 MB 09.24.07 at 10:58 am

Shasta Strumpet

or

Chandler’s Cinammon Tart

Quote

11 flytimes 09.24.07 at 11:04 am

“Bill the Cat” or BTC for short.
Accthppt!
WT

Quote

12 flytimes 09.24.07 at 11:06 am

“Yeah man, the big orange caddis were out in force but if you didn’t have a #10 BTC you were out of the game.”
Huh?! Huhhhhh?!

Quote

13 kbarton10 09.24.07 at 11:40 am

After I get all of the head cement out of the eye, it does resemble a well lipped Marlboro..

I’m thinking active, so “Turgid Nicotino” or “Tawny Turdlet”..that beast is as aerodynamic as a cupcake on kite string…

Quote

14 Freedog96150 09.24.07 at 12:37 pm

Orange Tang

Quote

15 Smellslikefish 09.24.07 at 1:06 pm

Spookaboo
Shasta Slattern
Burnt Umber Trollop – B.U.T.
Ochre Choker
So Many Fish So Little Time = SMFSLT = SmufSlut

Quote

16 Heddon 17 09.24.07 at 1:16 pm

Slaw Dog Special

Quote

17 ChrisW 09.24.07 at 1:37 pm

Smacks of a Ratty Looking Bushy Bugger to me.

Chris

p.s. I already have the book, so you can have that one for free.

Quote

18 C3C Raine 09.24.07 at 1:49 pm

wtf, you guys are some twisted-ass old men! In any case here’s my shot:

“Bug of Paradise”

Quote

19 BEAT LA! 09.24.07 at 2:32 pm

How about Mr. Orange or Orange Crush.

Quote

20 clara chandler 09.24.07 at 3:11 pm

Hi Kid, How about Hot Pepper Fly? Or do you live too far north to know about this? Mom

Quote

21 murdock 09.24.07 at 3:58 pm

I thought you were taking the day off? How about Chandler’s Bunion Bug?

I have the book already though.

Lee

Quote

22 Dmotes 09.24.07 at 3:58 pm

I’ve just read the list, and mine’s a loser, and also probably going to get me in trouble with somebody, but I feel like I’m among friends:

Readhead Stepchild

Dave

Quote

23 Dan 09.24.07 at 4:49 pm

Well, after two trips to the ER this weekend this resembles what shot out of the end of my third member finally after three agonizing pain filled days. So in honor of that, how about the GKS? That stands for the golden kidney stone.

Quote

24 Cameron D. 09.24.07 at 5:47 pm

How about Chandler’s October Mothra?

Quote

25 j. Dub 09.24.07 at 6:14 pm

Last Chance Caddis.

Quote

26 Dan 09.24.07 at 6:59 pm

Your problem is you dont do enough steelhead fishing. With the Trinity, Klamath, and rogue close by you have no excuse. Steelhead flies names ROCK.

Quote

27 Curly Friede 09.24.07 at 10:39 pm

Hard to get around the succinct:October Caddis. Or, keeping with current trends: Tom’s October Caddis. I checked, and nobody,s patented the name yet. So: Patent the obvious name – and if anybody else wants to name a fly for this insect: they have to pay you, or resort to one of the more outlandish names.

Quote

28 Burglar Bill 09.25.07 at 5:54 am

OK Tom, here goes:

Chandler’s Orange Caddylicious
Marmalade Mountain Mama
Dunsmuir Delight
The Scarlett O’Hara Way Bug (SOW BUG)
and
Tom’s (or Tommy’s) Little Orange Tickler

Best,
Bill

Quote

29 Burglar Bill 09.25.07 at 6:07 am

Tom,
I almost forgot.

The Cointreau California

Can you hear the soundtrack?

Better,
Bill

Quote

30 Alex 09.25.07 at 6:12 am

Candy Corn Caddis

Quote

31 flytimes 09.25.07 at 6:40 am

Now I’m starting to think that “Bill the Cat” has been taken. If there isn’t already a fly called the BTC then its a good name for this fly. If there is then I’m just a hack.
WT

Quote

32 Don 09.25.07 at 7:02 am

Chandler’s Chimera…heck, slaw dog was already taken

Quote

33 David Roberts 09.25.07 at 7:26 am

Cantera’s Tanker
(it kills fish all down river)
David

Quote

34 Arthur A Strauss 09.25.07 at 8:00 am

How about “The Scarecrow”?

Quote

35 Steve 09.25.07 at 8:22 am

Just so you can be proprietary:

Tom’s Dingle Berry

Steve

Quote

36 Paul Bruun 09.25.07 at 8:40 am

Hey, Tom,
With apologies to Reggie,
how about
MISTAH OCTOBER

Quote

37 Scott 09.25.07 at 11:17 am

Tangerine Dream Catcher (TDC)

Quote

38 Tom Chandler 09.25.07 at 11:23 am

Suddenly, I’m afraid of my own readership. Several of you are clearly cut out for serial killer-hood.

Still, you all may be crazy, but you’re the Underground’s crazies, which means you’re like family (only you don’t get to stay here when you visit).

I didn’t put a deadline on the contest, but I’ll probably pick a winner this weekend. Keep ‘em coming…

Quote

39 truckeetom 09.25.07 at 1:44 pm

pumpkin splash
flying gourd
the harvester
fall birdbug
Orange troutoverground

Quote

40 Roger W 09.25.07 at 4:38 pm

Here’s the winner:

” Sloptober Caddis ”

Quote

41 C3C Raine 09.25.07 at 4:39 pm

I don’t know if I’m allowed to submit twice but I don’t care either:

The U.F.O. – Underground’s Flying Orange

Quote

42 samistopdog 09.26.07 at 3:42 pm

Hold it, hold it …stop the press I got…damn thing kept up all night, ok I confess the jalapeno burger with extra habenaro chilies at 10:30 helped in the lack of sleep department…but blaming you is much cooler.

Quote

43 samistopdog 09.26.07 at 3:48 pm

this damn computoer cuts me off just like my wife does.

How about “Chandler’s Chippy”.

He says it’s one of his favorites(favorite what) and he does spend a lot of time away from the house and desk where he is to be entertaining us.So it figures he’s Chipping on the side with something…where is that bottle of Patron?

Quote

44 Gerry 09.27.07 at 4:48 pm

Caddis Cadaver
Or Chandler’s Caddis Cadaver
The Ailing Caddis (TAC)

Or invoking the Latin
Caddis terminatio
Caddis cadaverosus

Quote

45 Tom Chandler 09.27.07 at 6:02 pm

Ohh, Latin. Nice touch.

Quote

46 Curly Friede 09.27.07 at 9:17 pm

OK. Forgive me. Here it comes — Decumsmumus

Quote

47 Curly Friede 09.27.07 at 9:27 pm

WHOOPS — spelled it wrong-ok-Decumscumus

Quote

48 Curly Friede 09.28.07 at 1:30 am

Covering all the bases:
Egg Laying Decumscumus
or, the more discreet:
Adult Decumscumus

Quote

49 razmaspaz 09.28.07 at 8:10 am

I’m stealing a bit from Heddon 17, but “Slaw Caddis” sounds good.

Quote

50 greg hall 09.28.07 at 8:16 am

Fat Albert

Upper Sac Pimp Daddy

Jeeze, You’d think a guy who just turned 61 could be more dignified. Maybe it’s all the road food I had on my last fishing trip.

Quote

51 Steve 09.28.07 at 9:08 am

First, I would like to thank the Academy for selecting me, as winner of this prestigious Name a Fly award. Next I would like to thank each of you who helped make it happen… Thank you, thank you, thank you, thank you ….. (Music plays) Wait, what do you mean I lost? What do you mean you liked the faux(ny) latin names better?… I was robbed, I was robbed…. just because I wouldn’t pay shipping…

OH THE HUMANITY !!!

Steve

Quote

52 Shane 09.28.07 at 10:31 am

Since politics is on us for the next two years, and since you are so political fighting for conservation:

How about the “October Surprise”?

I know, not vulgar or catchy enough, but if you stare at it long enough . . . .

Shane

Quote

53 Curly Friede 09.28.07 at 11:08 am

One las shot at da book. If nothing else the exercise will serve to connect me with the brain prose center, and propell me toward the more important writing waiting on my dark desk. Though I prefer the more discriptive Saxon names, looks like those are pretty well covered, except for just this one: Orange Caddiddle (the second half being Gaelic in origin). Other than that the only names that come to mind are latin. I’ll submit just three, all with the same Saxon first name so that they might be a little more earthy:
Drunken Discoursmocus
leading to -
Drunken Decumscumus
the end result -
Drunken Discustmocus

Quote

54 Harry 09.28.07 at 1:27 pm

These are pretty lame but,

Chandlers Folly
No Chance Caddis
or
Fat CHance Caddis

What the hell, I’ll try anything caddis.

Quote

55 Gerry 09.28.07 at 8:24 pm

Chandler’s Caddis Candy

Quote

56 Gerry 09.28.07 at 8:31 pm

Adding to Harry’s entry
Last Chance Caddis

Quote

57 greg hall 09.29.07 at 9:21 am

It looks like this is still open so here’s a few more.

Tom’s Big Fat Caddis (TBFC)
Tom’s October Fat Butt
Tom’s Rocktober Caddis (TRC)

Save the postage Tom, I’ll just drive up pick up the book. :>))

Quote

58 flytimes 09.29.07 at 10:34 am

hackleberry caddis

Quote

59 flytimes 09.29.07 at 10:36 am

ahem, I mean Tom’s “Old Timey” Hackleberry Caddis.

Quote

60 kbarton10 09.29.07 at 12:52 pm

This still going? Jeez.

The Fluttering Cheeto.

Quote

61 C3C Raine 09.29.07 at 4:11 pm

How about:

Tom’s Special Hack-job (TuSH for short)

Quote

62 Curly Friede 09.29.07 at 5:42 pm

Still at it? Ran out of good names but figgered I might say that the fluttering hairwing version looks like its getting ready to fly away and these are strong flyers and trout know it and seldom attempt to eat them if they look too healthy. Hairwings take the odd fish if you insist on fishing dry, but if you hammer it out with a wetfly version you may see a better grade of fish. Try a clump wing of mottled turkey tail feather fibers; one turn of pheasant church window in front of the wing, then a turn of natural dark gray wool dubbing in front of the legs. Fish it dead-drift, wet. Individuals of these pupate and swim from the bottom as adults, so a Leisenring Lift at the end of the drift brings strikes. Good lookin hairwing though.

Quote

63 fishhead 09.30.07 at 6:31 pm

How about:

The Halloween Snot ball
or
Chandlers Belly button Lint ball?

Quote

64 Steve Altshuler 10.09.07 at 8:44 am

So, how will this fly be known forever more?
Tom?

Quote

65 Tom Chandler 10.10.07 at 9:57 am

I just announced the winner in a new post. And it wasn’t me…

Quote

66 Mike Glowacki 09.29.08 at 3:12 pm

copper-robber

Quote

Leave a Comment

You can use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Previous post: The Civilized Shore Lunch: Fly Fishing’s Missing Link

Next post: Turning Paperwork into Trout: The Underground Escapes the Office